Between science and ideological pressure: political reflection on civil war in Soviet Russia in 1917-1922

Бесплатный доступ

Introduction. The article explores the process and circumstances of understanding war as a political phenomenon in Soviet Russia 1917-1922, describes their impact on practice and theorydevelopment. For this purpose, the author studies the related political and ideological circumstances, characterizes the theory of class warfare and shows the specifics of understanding of the link between war and politics. Methodology and research methods. The methodologyis based on political realism and the recognition of war as a complex, volatile and contradictory political phenomenon. The article identifies the causality between the attitudes of the Soviet leadership, political practice and theoretical approaches to the study of war, taking into account real political situations, processes and decisions. Analysis. The study of war as a political phenomenon took place in the context of policy impact of the ideology and doctrinal principles of the state. Two approaches have emerged in the development of the theory of war. The first was characterized bya pronounced ideological perception of the war. The second approach was marked by the recognition of the political nature and determination of war, while avoiding the discussion on the mechanism ofimplementation of Soviet political institutions into military theoryand practice. Under these conditions, the synthesis of the two research paradigms was impossible. As a result, the first approach that didn’t recognize the existence of alternative points of view in the studyof war began to prevail. Results. In the early years of Soviet power, the scientific studyof war turned out to be secondaryin relation to the official ideological and doctrinal guidelines, which eventually began to formulate the comprehension of war as a political phenomenon. This situation, with minor changes, remained in the subsequent decades, which had consequences for the country’s defense and the use of military force.

Еще

Soviet Russia, theoryofwar, war as a political phenomenon, militarydoctrine, class warfare, civil war

Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/149141066

IDR: 149141066   |   DOI: 10.15688/jvolsu4.2022.4.6

Статья научная