Revisiting the issue of the “initial accumulation of capital” in post-Soviet Russia

Автор: Gulin Konstantin A.

Журнал: Economic and Social Changes: Facts, Trends, Forecast @volnc-esc-en

Рубрика: History of economic and sociological thought

Статья в выпуске: 6 (66) т.12, 2019 года.

Бесплатный доступ

The inclusion of those economies that are “peripheral” in relation to so-called “first world” countries into the paradigm of capitalist development is a topical issue of globalization. This process turned out extremely dramatic in its implications for former Soviet republics, in particular for post-Soviet Russia. The country, which had a highly capitalized economy “at the start” of market transformation, faced the fragmentation of socialized property and its transition to the form of private ownership. Politicians, public figures, experts, and scientists often interpret the stage of the 1990s “capitalist transition” from the standpoint of the “initial accumulation of capital” - a well-known category of Marxist political economy. However, we find this approach highly controversial. The goal of our paper is to find out whether it is legitimate to talk about the applicability of the key provisions of this theory to characterize the processes that took place in Russia in the first post-Soviet decade. This can be done by analyzing the theory of initial accumulation and its modern interpretations. In the first part of the article, we give a brief overview of the development of the theory of initial capital accumulation from its original provisions formulated byK. Marx to modern interpretations of this process. The second part considers the content of a discussion on the processes of post-Soviet capitalist transformation in Russia through the prism of the theory of initial accumulation. The third part uses actual data on the dynamics of fixed assets, gross fixed capital accumulation, investment activity to make a critical assessment of the processes of capitalist accumulation of capital in Russia in the last decade of the 20th century. We conclude that in the post-Soviet period there was a fragmentation of socialized property and its transition to private ownership, which contradicts the key provisions of the concept of initial accumulation (liquidation of property of small producers and its socialization). The novelty of the obtained results lies in the fact that the historical process that took place in Russia in the last decade of the 20th century was defined as a process of appropriation and secondary redistribution of state property, accompanied by catastrophic processes of decapitalization.


Capital, fixed assets, capital accumulation, initial accumulation, decapitalization

Короткий адрес:

IDR: 147224237   |   DOI: 10.15838/esc.2019.6.66.16

Список литературы Revisiting the issue of the “initial accumulation of capital” in post-Soviet Russia

  • Marx K. Capital. A Critique of Political Economy. Vol. 1. Book I: The process of capital production. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo politicheskoi literatury, 1952. 794 p.
  • Frank A.G. World Accumulation, 1492-1789. New York: Monthly Review Press, 1978. 303 p.
  • Amin S. Accumulation on a World Scale. A Critique of the Theory of Underdevelopment. New York: Monthly Review Press, 1974. 648 p.
  • Bonefeld W. Primitive Accumulation and Capitalist Accumulation. Science & Society, 2011, vol. 75, no. 3, pp. 379-399.
  • De Angelis M. Marx and "primitive accumulation": the continuous character of capital's "enclosures". The Commoner, 2001, no. 2, pp. 1-22.
  • Perelman M. A Short History of Primitive Accumulation. Available at:
  • Hardt M., Negri A. Imperialism. Cambridge, London: Harvard University Press, 2000. 478 p.
  • Harvey D. The New Imperialism. Oxford University Press, 2003. 253 p.
  • Gaidar E.T. Gosudarstvo i evolyutsiya. Dni porazhenii i pobed [State and evolution. Days of defeats and victories]. Moscow: Evraziya, 1997. 552 p.
  • Yasin E. Prizhivetsya li demokratiya v Rossii [Will democracy take root in Russia]. Moscow: Novoe izdatel'stvo, 2005. 384 p.
  • Berezovskii B. Avtoportret, ili Zapiski poveshennogo [A self-portrait or the Notes of a hanged man]. Мoscow: Tsentrpoligraf, 2013. 360 p.
  • Dzarasov S.S. Marksova kontseptsiya pribavochnoi stoimosti sokhranyaet svoyu silu [The concept of surplus value remains valid]. In: Voyeikov M.I. (Ed.). Karl Marks: klassika i sovremennost' (k 200-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya) [Karl Marx: classics and modernity (to the 200th anniversary)]. Мoscow: IE RAS, 2018. 114 p.
  • Dolmatova S.A. Problema pervonachal'nogo nakopleniya kapitala v postsovetskoi Rossii [The problem of initial capital accumulation in post-soviet Russia]. Karl Marks: klassika i sovremennost' (k 200-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya)=Karl Marx: classics and modernity (to the 200th anniversary). Мoscow: IE RAS, 2018. 114 p.
  • Biryukov V.A. Features of initial capital accumulation in Russia. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 6. Ekonomika=Moscow University Economics Bulletin, 2001, no. 4, pp. 19-43. (In Russian).
  • Barzakovskii A.S. Vozdeistvie protsessa pervonachal'nogo nakopleniya kapitala na formirovanie i realizatsiyu ekonomicheskikh interesov v postsovetskoi Rossii: avtoref. diss. na soisk. uch. step. kand. ekonom. nauk [The impact of the process of initial capital accumulation on the formation and implementation of economic interests in post-soviet Russia: Candidate of Sciences (Economics) dissertation abstract]. Tambov, 2009. 26 p.
  • Plyshevskii B. Capital accumulation in post-soviet period. Ekonomist= Economist, 2016, no. 9, pp. 22-36.
  • Korostelev A. Delo "Noril'skii nikel'". Privat-kapitalizm Rossii [Case "Norilsk Nickel". Private capitalism of Russia]. Мoscow: Algoritm, 2008. 1152 p.
  • Mandel D. Primitive accumulation in post-soviet Russia. In: Vidal M., Smith T., Rotta T., Prew P. (Eds.). The Oxford Handbook of Karl Marx. Oxford University Press, 2019.
  • Tonkiss F. Contemporary Economic Sociology: Globalization, Production, Inequality. London and New York: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 2006. 197 p.
  • Clarke S. The Development of Capitalism in Russia. London and New York: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 2007. 249 p.
  • Brass T. Capitalism, Primitive Accumulation and Unfree Labour. In: Imperialism, Crisis and Class Struggle. The Enduring Verities and Contemporary Face of Capitalism by Henry Veltmeyer. Leiden-Boston: Brill, 2010. Pp. 67- 132.
  • Holmstrom N., Smith R. The necessity of gangster capitalism. primitive accumulation in Russia and China. Montly Review, 2000, vol. 51, no. 9. Available at: https://monthly href='contents.asp?titleid=22910' title='Review'>
  • Kozlov V.A., Korobkova N.P. The theory of "primitive accumulation": the urgent adjustments. "Izvestiya of Altai State University" Journal=Proceedings of Altai State University, 2014, no. 4, vol. 1, pp. 115-119. (In Russian).
  • Simchenko N.A., Tsekhla S.Yu., Poteev A.T. et al. Marksistskaya ekonomicheskaya teoriya v istorii kapitalizatsii v Rossii: monografiya [Marxist economic theory in the history of capitalization in Russia: monograph]. Simferopol: ARIAL, 2018. 376 p.
  • Gukas'yan G.M., Makhovikova G.M., Amosova V.V. Ekonomicheskaya teoriya: uchebnik [Economic theory: textbook]. 2nd edition. Moscow: Eksmo, 2011, 736 p.
  • Shalamov G.A., Pushkareva O.I. Karl Marx on the role of theft in the period of initial capital accumulation. Vestnik Irkutskogo gosudarstvennogo tehnicheskogo universiteta=Proceedings of Irkutsk State Technical University, 2012, no. 11, pp. 298-302. (In Russian).
  • Tsvetkov V.A. Korporativnyi biznes: Teoriya i praktika [Corporate business: Theory and practice]. Saint Petersburg: Nestor-Istoriya, 2011, 504 p.
  • Krasnikova E.V. Market transformation of the Russian economy as a process of initial capital accumulation. Voprosy Ekonomiki=Economic Issues, 2001, no. 2, pp. 142-154. (In Russian).
  • Krasnikova E.V. Paradoksy ekonomicheskogo razvitiya Rossii XIX-XX vekov [Paradoxes of economic development of Russia in the 19-20 centuries]. Moscow: Ekonomika, 2009, 327 p. (In Russian)
  • Simonyan R.Kh., Kochegarova T.M. Traumatic experience of the 1990s as a lesson for Russian society. Rossiya i sovremennyi mir=Russia and the contemporary world, 2014, no. 4, pp. 108-123. (In Russian).
  • Burawoy M. Transition without transformation: Russia's involutionary road to capitalism. East European Politics and Societies, 2001, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 269-290.
  • Kotz D.M. Is Russia becoming capitalist? Science & Society, 2001, vol. 65, no. 2, pp. 157-181.
  • Lebskii M.A. Novyi russkii kapitalizm: ot zarozhdeniya do krizisa (1986-2018) [New Russian capitalism: from its inception to the crisis (1986-2018)]. Moscow: Lenand, 2019, 200 p.
  • Beznin M.A., Dimoni T.M. On the question of state capitalism in the USSR in the 1930s-the 1980s (some theses of the new approach). Vestnik Vologodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya "Gumanitarnye, obshchestvennye i pedagogicheskie nauki"=Bulletin of Vologda State University. Linguistics, 2016, no.3, pp. 8-14. (In Russian).
  • Khanin G.I. Ekonomicheskaya istoriya Rossii v noveishee vremya. Rossiiskaya ekonomika v 1992-1998 godakh: monografiya [Economic history of Russia in modern times. Russian economy in 1992-1998: monograph]. Novosibirsk: Izd-vo NGTU, 2014. 712 p.
  • Men'shikov S.M. Anatomiya rossiiskogo kapitalizma [Anatomy of Russian capitalism]. Moscow: Mezhdunar. otnosheniya, 2004. 432 p.
  • Val'tukh K.A. A mobilization economic strategy is required. EKO= ECO, 2000, no. 11, pp. 3-20. (In Russian).
  • Khanin G.I., Fomin D.A. Consumption and accumulation of fixed capital in Russia: an alternative assessment. Problemy prognozirovaniya=Studies on Russian Economic Development, 2007, no.1, pp. 26-50. (In Russian).
  • Voskoboynikov I.B. Nerynochnyi kapital i ego vliyanie na dinamiku investitsii v rossiiskoi ekonomike [Non-market capital and its impact on investment dynamics in the Russian economy], Moscow: IEPP, 2004, 90 p.
  • Men'shikov S.M. Sovetskaya ekonomika: katastrofa ili katarsis [Soviet economy: catastrophe or catharsis]. Moscow: International. relations, 1990. 397 p.
  • Kliff T. Gosudarstvennyi kapitalizm v Rossii [State capitalism in Russia]. Leningrad: Sotsialisticheskii rabochii, 1991. 288 p.
  • Il'in V.A. "Crony capitalism" - a source of social inequality in modern Russia. Ekonomicheskie i sotsial'nye peremeny: fakty, tendentsii, prognoz=Economic and Social Changes: Facts, Trends, Forecast, 2017, vol. 10, no. 6, pp. 9-23. (In Russian).
  • Gubanov S. Neo-industrialization plus vertical integration (on the formula of development of Russia). Ekonomist=Economist, 2008, no. 9, pp. 3-27. (In Russian).
Статья научная