Russian-Norwegian borderland in the foreign historical literature in the 20th — beginning of the 21st centuries

Автор: Konstantin S. Zaikov

Журнал: Arctic and North @arctic-and-north

Рубрика: Historical sciences

Статья в выпуске: 30, 2018 года.

Бесплатный доступ

The article presents a review of foreign research on the history of Russian-Norwegian borderland in 16th — early 20th centuries. The dominance of the empirical positivism and historical nationalism in the history of the Northern frontier delimitation led to the formation of relatively stable and unilateral interpretations of the Russian-Norwegian border in the first half of the 20th century. The state was perceived as an a priori objective phenomenon. That’s why historians and legal scholars understood the “border” as a static instrument of political power, ignoring its multipotential phenomena and variety of its subjects. The Scandinavian historiography has developed a historical tradition of perception of the Treaty 1826 on the delimitation of “common districts” as a fair act of institutionalization of borders over the common possession. As a part of this tradition, it may seem that Norwegian territorial claims did not look expansive in relation to Russia. However, for a long time the Scandinavian historians advocated the theory that the Russian Empire, driven by the idea of permanent territorial extensions, had posed a threat to the Norwegian Finmark. So, the delineation of the Northern frontier was a diplomatic deal aimed at creating legitimate barriers to further Russian expansion in Western Europe through the Norwegian Arctic. Thus, the author con-cludes that from the methodological perspective, the evolution of the Russian-Norwegian borderlands is still not sufficiently developed in foreign historiography and requires closer attention to create high-quality reconstruction of the Russian-Norwegian borderland evolution from the territory with frontlines configura-tion of political boundaries in the 13th century — the early 19th century to the space with a sealed political boundary in the 20th century.

Еще

History, border, frontier, historiography, the Russian-Norwegian relations, the Russian-Norwegian borderland, the Sami

Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/148318547

IDR: 148318547   |   DOI: 10.17238/issn2221-2698.2018.30.60

Список литературы Russian-Norwegian borderland in the foreign historical literature in the 20th — beginning of the 21st centuries

  • Paasi A. Mapping the Backgrounds, Contexts and Contests. B/ordering Space. Ed. by H. Van Houtum, O. Kramsch, W. Zierhofer. Aldershot, 2005, pp. 19–22.
  • Minghi J. Changing Geographies of Scale and Hierarchy in European Borderlands. Boundaries and Place, European Borderlands in Geographical Сontext. Ed. by D.H. Kaplan, J. Häkli. Oxford, 2002, pp. 36–37.
  • Häkli J. Borders in the political geography of knowledge. The Dividing line: borders and national pe-ripheries. Ed. by L-F. Landgren, M. Häyrynen. Helsinki, 1997, pp. 11–12.
  • Johnsen O.A. Finmarkens politiske historie, aktmæssing fremstillet. Skrifter utgitt av Det norske vi-denskapsakademi i Oslo, II, Hist. fil. Klasse. Kristiania, Jacob Debwad Publ., 1922. 357 s.
  • Zaikov K. The history of the Northern frontier delimitation (1822–1826) in the light of the Russian and European historiography: the interpretation and perceptual problems. Bylye Gody, 2016, no. 42(4), pp. 1164–1172.
  • Tanner V. Antropogeografiska studier inom Petsamo–området. I. Skolt–Lapparna. Helsingfors, 1929. 518 s.
  • Kuchinskii M.G. Sami Kol'skogo uezda v XVI–XVIII vekakh. Model' sotsial'noi struktury [The Sami of the Kola district in the XVI–XVII centuries. Model of social structure]. Alta, 2008. 294 p. (In Russ.)
  • Kristiansen T. «Russkie gubyat nas; Oni lishayut nas sredstv k propitaniyu…»: Russko-norvezhskie otnosheniya na Krainem Severe do 1820 ["The Russians are ruining us; They deprive us of the means to subsistence ...”: Russian-Norwegian relations before 1820]. Russkii sbornik [Russian An-thology]. Ed. by O.R. Airapetov, M. Iovanovich, M.A. Kolerov, B. Menning, P. Cheisti. Moscow, 2010, pp. 26–52. (In Russ.)
  • Niemi E. Etnisitet, nasjonalitet og grenseforhold i det nordligste Skandinavia fram til vår tid. Grenser og grannelag i Nordens historie. Red. S. Imsen. Oslo, 2005, ss. 387–415.
  • Nielsen J.P., Zaikov K. Norway’s Hard and Soft Borders towards Russia. Imagined, Negotiated, Re-membered. Constructing European Borders and Borderlands. Ed. by K. Katajala, M. Lähteenmäki. Münster, 2012, pp. 67–86.
  • Lunde A. Sør Varanger Historie Med bidrag av Povl Simonsen og Ørnulv Vorren. Vadsø, Sør-Varanger kommune, 1979. 887 s.
  • Wikan S. Grensebygda Neiden. Møte mellom folkegrupper og kampen om ressursene. Svanvik, 1995. 473 s.
  • Andresen A. Sii’daen som forsvant. Østsamene i Pasvik etter den norsk-russisk grensetrekningen i 1826. Kirkenes, Sør-Varanger Museum, 1989. 192 s.
  • Andresen A. Russiske Østsamers Rettigheter i Norge 1826–1925. Myndighetspolitikk og Ret-tighetsproblematikk. Hovedoppgave i Historie. Tromsø, 1983. 150 s.
  • Nielsen J.P. Some Reflections on the Norwegian-Russian Border and the Evolution of State Border in General. Russia-Norway. Physical and Symbolic Borders. Ed. by T.N. Jackson, J.P. Nielsen. Moscow, 2005, pp. 7–16.
  • Lähteenmäki M. The peoples of Lapland. Boundary demarcation and interaction in the North Callote from 1808 to 1889. Helsinki, 2006. 335 p.
  • Roginsky V.V. The 1826 Delimitation Convention between Norway and Russia: A Diplomatic Chal-lenge. Russia — Norway. Physical and Symbolic Borders. Ed. by T.N. Jackson, J.P. Nielsen. Moscow, 2005, pp. 162–168.
  • Roginskiy V.V. Konventsiya 1826 g. o razgranichenii mezhdu Norvegiey i Rossiey kak diplomatich-eskaya problema [1826 Convention on Border Delimitation Between Norway and Russia as a Diplo-matic issue]. Vestnik “Barents-tsentra” MGPU, 2008, no. 7, pp. 25–30.
  • Kristoman B.B. Istoriya nauchno-promyslovogo osvoeniya Evropeiskogo Severa v kontekste politich-eskikh interesov Rossiiskoi Imperii v XIX — nachale XX vv.: dis. … kand. ist. nauk [The history of scien-tific and commercial development of the European North in the context of political interests of the Russian Empire in the XIX – early XX centuries: Cand. Sci. (Hist.) diss.]. Arkhangelsk, Pomor State University Publ., 2003.
  • Kasiyan A.S. Laplandskii vopros v rossiisko-norvezhskikh otnosheniyakh: razgranichenie 1826 g. i ego posledstviya v nachale XX v. [The Lapland issue in Russian-Norwegian relations: the demarcation of 1826 and its consequences at the beginning of the 20th century]. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya na Severe Evropy i Barentsev region: istoriya i istoriografiya: sbornik nauchnykh statei [International re-lations in the North of Europe and the Barents Region: history and historical literature]. Ed. by Yu.P. Bardileva. Murmansk, 2008, pp. 141–149. (In Russ.)
  • Palmstierna C.F. Sverige, Ryssland och England 1833–1855. Krig November traktaens Förutsättningar. Stockholm, 1932. 408 s.
  • Borodkin M. Istoriya Finlyandii. Vremya Imperatora Nikolaya I [History of Finland. Time of the Em-peror Nicholas I]. Saint Petersburg, 1915. 716 p. (In Russ.)
  • Pokhlebkin V. Rossiya pervoi priznala norvezhskuyu nezavisimost' [Russia was the first to recognize Norwegian independence]. Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn' [International affairs], 1997, no. 5, pp. 48–61.
  • Ryvarden L., Lauritsen P.R. Norges grense: fra Grisebåen til Barentshavet. Oslo, Cappelen, 2005. 255 s.
  • Eriksen K.E., Niemi E. Den finske fare: Sikkerhetsproblemer og minoritetspolitikk i nord 1860–1940. Oslo, 1983. 470 s.
  • Niemi E. Kirka som grensefestning: kirkebyggning, religiøs spenning og grensesikring i Finmark 1850–1940. Forpost mot øst: fra Vardø og Finmarks historie 1307–2007: rapport fra det XXXII nord-norske historieseminar, Vardø 21–23 september 2007. Ed. by R.R. Balsvik, J.P. Nielsen. Stamsund, 2008, pp. 153–166.
  • Nielsen J.P. The Russia of the Tsar and North Norway. ”The Russian danger” Revisited. Acta Boreal-ia, 2002, no. 1, pp. 75–92.
  • Nielsen J.P. Norwegian Images of Russia and the Russians. Rossiya i Zapad. Istoricheskii opyt XIX–XX vekov [Russia and the West. Historical experience of the XIX−XX centuries]. Ed. by M.A. Lipkin. Mos-cow, 2008, pp. 241–246.
  • Tønnesen S. Retten til jorden i Finnmark: rettsreglene om den såkaldte «statens umatrikkulerte grunn»: en undersøkelse med særlig sikt på samenes rettigheter. Oslo, Universitetsforlaget, 1979. 414 s.
  • Ishizuka M. Norwegian-Russian Borderland in Transition: Spatial Perception among Norwegian Elites in 1826–1852. Russia — Norway. Physical and Symbolic Borders. Ed. by T.N. Jackson, J.P. Nielsen. Moscow, 2005, pp. 95–104.
Еще
Статья научная