Social factors and suicide: comparing the regional concomitants of Eastern European suicide mortality over the 20th century
Автор: Ilkka Henrik Mkinen
Журнал: Суицидология @suicidology
Статья в выпуске: 2 (19) т.6, 2015 года.
Бесплатный доступ
The aim of this study was to investigate the social concomitants of Eastern European suicide mortality before and at the end of the Communist period, and whether these changed across time. Regional (guberniya, oblast, etc.) data on suicide mortality and several possible concomitants such as alcohol consumption, homicide rates, divorce rates, urbanity etc. were collected from Czarist "European Russia” in 1910 and from the corresponding areas in 1989. These concomitants of suicide mortality were studied with the help of correlative and regressive techniques. The main regional concomitants of suicide mortality in Eastern Europe in 1910 were urban living, economic wealth, and divorce, all urban phenomena. In 1989, the main concomitants varied somewhat between the different countries, but homicide, general mortality, and alcohol consumption (in Russia) were often positively related to suicide. The instability of the concomitants to suicide is a consequence of the fact that the nature of suicide in Eastern Europe has changed from being an urban, middle- and upper-class phenomenon into a more conventional social problem, which may be reflected even in the social character of contemporary Eastern European suicide as such. While suicide mortality has to some extent followed lawlessness and alcohol consumption, the changing covariates show that the “social correlates of suicide” are culture-bound and thus flexible. Any ethnic/genetic hypotheses of the distribution of suicide must take this fact into account.
Alcohol, cross-sectional studies, divorce, economy, eastern europe, history, homicide, poland, Russia, suicide
Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/140141460
IDR: 140141460
Список литературы Social factors and suicide: comparing the regional concomitants of Eastern European suicide mortality over the 20th century
- Sartorius N. Recent changes in suicide rates in selected Eastern European and Other European countries//International Psychogeriatrics. -1995. -№7. -Р. 301-308.
- Mäkinen I.H. Eastern European transition and suicide mortality//Social science & medicine. -2000. -№ 51. -Р. 1405-1420.
- Jarosz M. Suicide. Warsaw: Institute of political studies at Polish Academy of Sciences, 1998.
- Värnik A. Suicide in the Baltic countries and in the former republics of the USSR. Stockholm: National Swedish and Stockholm county council of suicide research and prevention & Dept. of clinical neuroscience at Karolinska Institute, 1997 (a).
- Kondrichin S.V., Lester D. Suicide in the Ukraine//Crisis. -2002. -№ 23. -Р. 32-33.
- Pridemore W.A., Spivak A.L. Patterns of suicide mortality in Russia//Suicide and life-threatening behavior. -2003. -№ 33. -Р. 132-150.
- Pridemore W.A. Heavy drinking and suicide in Russia//Social forces. -2006. -№ 85. -Р. 413-430.
- Andreeva E., Ermakov S., Brenner H. The Socioeconomic aetiology of suicide mortality in Russia//International journal of environment and sustainable development. -2008. -№ 7. -Р. 21-48.
- Razvodovsky Y.E., Stickley A. Suicide in urban and rural regions of Belarus, 1990-2005//Public health. -2009. -№ 23. -Р. 27-31.
- Värnik A. Enesetapud Eestis 1965-1995. -Tallinn: Estonian-Swedish Suicidology Institute, 1997 (b).
- Yunatskevich P.I., Gilinskii Y.I. Sotsiologicheskie i psikhologo-pedagogicheskie osnovy suitsidologii. Uchebnoe posobie. -St.Petersburg: Russian academy of sciences, Institute of sociology, 1999.
- Mäkinen, I.H. Sorokin on suicide. An introduction to his essay “Suicide as a social phenomenon”. In Vågerö D. (Ed.). The Unknown Sorokin. His life in Russia and the essay on suicide. -Stockholm: Södertörn university college & CHESS, 2002. -P. 32-61.
- Mäkinen I.H. Suicide mortality of Eastern European regions before and after the communist period//Social science and medicine. -2006. -№ 63. -Р. 307-319.
- Gilinskii Y., Rumyantseva G. Samoubiistva v Rossii//Mir Rossii. -1998. -Р. 6.
- Bogoyavlenskii D.D. Rossiiskie Samoubiistva i rossiiskie reformy//Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. -2002. -Р. 76-80.
- Värnik A., Wasserman D., Dankowicz M., Eklund G. Age-specific suicide rates in the Slavic and Baltic Regions of the former USSR during Perestroika, in comparison with 22 European countries//Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. -1998). -№ 98, Suppl. -Р. 20-25.
- Girard C. Age, gender, and suicide: a crossnational analysis//American sociological review. -1993. -№ 58. -Р. 553-574.
- Mäkinen I.H., Beskow J., Jansson A., Odén B. Historical perspectives on suicide and suicide prevention in Sweden//Archives of suicide research. -2002. -№ 6. -Р. 269-284.
- Mäkinen I.H. The importance of culture for suicide research/In Mäkinen I.H. On suicide in European countries. Some historical, legal, and theoretical aspects on suicide mortality and its concomitants. -Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell, 1997 (b).
- Diekstra R.F.W. The epidemiology of suicide and parasuicide//Acta Psych. Scand. -1993. -Vol. 371 (Suppl.). -P. 9-20.
- Durkheim E. Suicide. -London: Routledge, 1992.
- Sainsbury P., Jenkins J., Levey A. The social correlates of suicide in Europe/In Farmer, R. & Hirsch, S. (Eds.)/The suicide syndrome. -London: Croom Helm, 1980. -P. 38-53.
- Mäkinen I.H. Are there social correlates to suicide?//Social science and medicine. -1997 (a). -№ 44. -Р. 1919-1929.
- Novoselskii S.A. Statistika samoubiistv//Gigieniya i sanitariya. -1910. -№ 8-10. Suppl.
- Korovin A.M. Samoubiistva i Potreblenie Vodki v Evropeiskoi Rossii s 1903-go po 1912-ii God. -Moscow: Snegirev, 1916.
- Zhbankov D. Sovremenniya Samoubiistva//Sovremennoi mir. -1910. -№ 3. -Р. 27-63.
- Grigorev N. Samoubiistva v g. S.-Peterburg za pervuyu polovinu 1910 g.//Vrachebnaya Gazeta. -1910. -№ 36. -Р. 106.
- Lester D., Kondrichin S.V. The ecological variation of suicide in Russia and the United States//European journal of psychiatry. -2000. -№ 14. -Р. 79-84.
- Kandrychyn S. Geographic variation in suicide rates: relationships to social factors, migration, and ethnic history//Archives of suicide research. -2004. -№ 8. -Р. 303-314.
- Voracek M., Loibl L.M., Kandrychyn S. Testing the finno-ugrian suicide hypothesis: replication and refinement with regional suicide data from Eastern Europe//Perceptual and Motor Skills. -2007. -№ 104. -Р. 985-994.
- Voitsekhovich B.A., Redko A.N. Pust umiraet tot, kto ne khochet zhit? -Krasnodar: Kuban scientific medical journal edition, 1994.
- Mokhovikov A., Donets O. Suicide in the Ukraine: epidemiology, knowledge, and attitudes of the population//Crisis. -1996. -№ 17. -Р. 128-134.
- Nemtsov A. Suicides and alcohol consumption in Russia, 1965-1999//Drug and alcohol dependence. -2003. -№ 71. -Р. 161-168.
- Razvodovsky Y.E. Suitsidy i uroven potrebleniya alkogolya//Problemy sotsialnoi gigieny,zdravookhraneniya i istorii meditsiny. -2003. -P. 22-25.
- Brainerd E. Economic reform and mortality in the former Soviet Union: a study of the suicide epidemic in the 1990s”//European economic review. -2001. -№ 45. -Р. 1007-1019.
- Orlova I.B. Samoubiistvo kak indikator ob-shchestvennogo regressa/In Osipov G., Levashov V., Lokosov V. (Eds.)//Rossiya: novyi etap neoliberalnykh reform. Sotsialnaya i sotsialno-politicheskaya situatsiya v Rossii v pervoi polovine 1997 goda. -Moscow: Respublika, 1997. -P. 123-129.
- Kryzhanovskaya L., Pilyagina G. Suicidal behavior in the Ukraine, 1988-1998//Crisis. -1999. -№ 20. -Р. 184-190.
- Isak O.V. Samoubiistva v Moldove s positsii kontseptsii E. Dyurkgeima//Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. -2004. -P. 116-120.
- Orlova I.B. Samoubiistvo -yavlenie sotsialnoe//Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. -1998. -№ 8. -Р. 69-73.
- Pridemore W.A., Chamlin M.B., Cochran J.K. An interrupted time-series analysis of durkheim's social deregulation thesis: the case of the Russian Federation//Justice Quarterly. -2007. -№ 24. -Р. 271-290.
- Rancans E., Salander Renberg E., Jacobsson L. Major demographic, social and economic factors associated to suicide rates in Latvia 1980-98//Acta Psychiatr. Scand. -2001. -№ 103. -Р. 275-281.
- Stickley A., Mäkinen I.H. Homicide in the Russian empire and Soviet Union. Continuity or change?//British Journal of Criminology. -2005. -№ 45. -Р. 647-670.
- Novoselskii S.A. Obzor glavneishikh dannykh po demografii i sanitarnoi statistiki Rossii/In Bulatov B.N. (Ed.)//Kalendar dlya vrachei vsekh vedomstv na 1916 god. Chast II, 1916. -P. 14-94. -Petrograd: K.L. Rikker.
- Otchet o sostoyanii narodnago zdraviya. -St.Petersburg: Upravlenie glavnago vrachebnago inspektora MVD, 1912.
- Wasserman D., Värnik A. Reliability of statistics on violent death and suicide in the former USSR, 1970-1990//Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. -1998 (a). -№ 98, Suppl. -Р. 34-41.
- Wasserman D., Värnik A. Suicide-preventive effects of Perestroika in the former USSR: the role of alcohol restriction//Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. -1998 (b). -№ 98, Suppl. -Р. 1-4.
- Smolitsch I. Geschichte der russischen Kirche 1700-1917. -Leiden: Brill, 1964.
- Vlasova I.V. Istoriko-kulturnye zony Rossii/In Aleksandrov V.A., Vlasova I.V., Polishchuk N.S. (Eds.), Russkie. -Moscow: Nauka, 1997. -P. 107-108.
- Zubov I.O. Samoubiistvo v Liflyandskoi gubernii//Mediko-statisticheskii ocherk. -Tartu: Mattisen, 1903.
- Bills C.B., Li, G. Correlating homicide and suicide//International journal of epidemiology. -2005. -№ 34. -Р. 837-845.
- Henry A., Short J. Homicide and suicide. -New York: Free Press, 1954.
- Klebba J.A. Comparison of trends for suicide and homicide in the United States, 1900-1976/In Hays, J.R., Roberts, T.K., Solway, K.S. (Eds.) Violence and the Violent Individual. -1981. -Р. 127-148. Lancaster: MTP Press Ltd.
- Ramstedt M. Alcohol and suicide in 14 European countries//Addiction. -2001. -№ 96. -S. 59-S76.
- Landberg J. Alcohol and suicide in Eastern Europe//Drug and alcohol review. -2008. -№ 27. -Р. 361-373.
- Maksimova T.M., Belov V.B., Rogovina A.G. Ubiistva i samoubiistva kak problema obshchshestvennego zdorovya//Problemy sotsialnoi gigieny i zdravookhraneniya. -2006. -№ 1. -Р. 11-14.
- Mäkinen I.H. The acceptance of suicide and its concomitants in Eastern and Western Europe in times of transition/In Holyst B. (Ed.).//EuroCriminology. -2007. -Vol. 20/21. -P. 3-27. -Lodz: Lodz University Press.
- Humphrey C. Alternative freedoms//Proceedings of the American philosophical society. -2007. -№ 151. -Р. 1-10.
- Sapozhnikov D.I. Samosozhzheniye v russkom raskole so vtoroi poloviny XVII veka do kontsa XVIII veka. Istoricheskii ocherk po arkhivnym dokumentam. -Moscow: Universitetskaya tipografiya, 1891.
- Solzhenitsyn A. The Gulag Archipelago 19181956. An experiment in literary investigation. -London: Collins Harvill, 1974-78. -Vol. I-III.
- Kondrichin S.V., Lester D. Suicide in Belarus//Crisis. -1998. -№ 19. -Р. 167-171.