Some reflections concerning the phiale with the images of Heracles and Auge from the Rogozen treasure

Автор: Treister Mikhail

Журнал: Материалы по археологии и истории античного и средневекового Причерноморья @maiask

Статья в выпуске: S1, 2022 года.

Бесплатный доступ

One of the most important finds from the richest of the Thracian hoards, the Rogozen Treasure, is the so- called Auge Phiale. Its chronological position is crucial for the dating of the Hoard and had already been a point of debates. Its decoration, which consists of a mythological scene in high relief occupying the interior of the flat bottom and a relief pattern of alternating palmettes and lotus flowers grouped around the central rosette on the outside is discussed, thus allow us not only to determine the position of the vessel among the masterpieces of the Late Classical/Early Hellenistic metalware, but also to dwell on the genesis of the main subject of the composition. Clarifying the chronological position of the phiale is also extremely important for the establishment of the date, when the Treasure was hidden.Both the analysis of the general shape, the construction and composition of the elements of the vessel, the ornamental patterns decorating its bottom and the parallels of the figural composition on the inner medallion do not allow dating earlier than 350/340 BCE. Moreover, there is strong evidence that the phiale should be dated in the chronological frames of the last quarter of the 4th - first decades of the 3rd century BCE. The shape of the vessel and the decoration of its bottom may suggest a somewhat earlier dating, whereas that of the medallion - somewhat later, within the frames of the chronological period mentioned above. Thus, it may be a further confirmation of the history of the vessel, reconstructed on the grounds of its technological examination.This is not the only vessel from the Rogozen Treasure for which a dating after 340 BCE and as late as the last quarter of the 4th/early 3rd century BCE, first decades or even the second quarter of the 3rd century BCE has been already proposed. Consequently, it provides another argument that the Treasure was buried much later than it was usually suggested before (330s BCE).

Еще

Thrace, rogozen treasure, scythia, greek toreutics, phialai, palmettes, vessel medallions, heracles, auge, iconography

Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/14126099

IDR: 14126099 | DOI: 10.53737/2713-2021.2022.34.33.001

Список литературы Some reflections concerning the phiale with the images of Heracles and Auge from the Rogozen treasure

Abka'i-Khavari, M. 1988. Die achämenidischen Metallschallen. Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran 21, 91—137.
Alekseev, A.Yu. 2012. Zoloto skifskikh tsarey v sobranii Ermitazha (Gold of the Scythian Kings in the Collection of the Hermitage). Saint Petersburg: State Hermitage (in Russian).
Alekseev, A.Yu. 2018. In: Polin, S.V., Alekseev, A.Yu. Skifskiy tsarskiy Aleksandropol'skiy kurgan IVv. do n.e. v Nizhnem Podneprov'e (Scythian Royal Alexandropol Burial mound of the 4th Century BCE in the Lower Dnieper Region). Kyiv: Oleg Filyuk, 466—590 (Burial mounds of the Ukraine 6) (in Russian).
Ambrosini, L. 2020. La violenza di Herakles su Auge. Studio del procedimento produttivo di pissidi in ceramica argentata e dorata da Lipari derivate da specchi a teca di bronzo. Mediterranea. Studi e ricerche sul mediterraneo antico XVII, 87—106.
Andronicos, M. 1993. Vergina: The Royal Tombs and the Ancient City. Athens: Ekdotike Athenon.
Andronikos, M. 1987. Bspyiva. AvaoKa^n 1987. AErgMak 1 (1987), 81—88.
Antonov, D., Torbov, N. 2002. Bronze Tools with Human Effigies found in Northwestern Bulgaria. In: Giumlia-Mair, A. (ed.). I Bronzi antichi: Produzioni e tecnologia. Atti del XV Congresso Internazionale sui Bronzi Antichi. Montagnac: Éditions Monique Mergoil, 571—580 (Instrumentum Monographies 21).
arachne.dainst.org: 1: Friesblock. Available at: arachne.dainst.org/entity/1137404 (accessed 01.10.2022).
arachne.dainst.org: 2: Friesblock der korinthischen Ordnung mit Lotus-Palmettenfries. Available at: arachne.dainst.org/entity/1182827 (accessed 01.10.2022).
arachne.dainst.org: 3: Friesblock der korinthischen Ordnung mit Lotus-Palmettenfries. Available at: arachne.dainst.org/entity/1182819 (accessed 01.10.2022).
arachne.dainst.org: 4: Friesblock der korinthischen Ordnung mit Lotus-Palmettenfries. Available at: arachne.dainst.org/entity/1182821 (accessed 01.10.2022).
arachne.dainst.org: 5: Palmetten-Antefix. Available at: arachne.dainst.org/entity/1326934 (accessed 01.10.2022).
Archibald, Z.H. 1989. Thracian Interpretations of Greek and Oriental Elements in Fourth-Century Metalwork. In: Cook, B.F. (ed.). The Rogozen Treasure, Papers of the Anglo-Bulgarian Conference, 12 March 1987. London: British Museum, 12—25.
Archibald, Z.H. 1998. The Odrysian Kingdom of Thrace. Orpheus Unmasked. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Artamonow, M. I. 1970. Goldschatz der Skythen. Prague: Artia.
Avramidou, A., Tsiafaki, D. 2015. ATTIKHKEPAMIKH. Lv^ßoX^ otiç snayéç AOqvaç Kai OpàKtfç. Athens: EAAHNIKA AKAAHMAÏKA HAEKTPONIKA ZYrrPAMMATA KAI BOH0HMATA.
Axmann, U. 1986. Hellenistische Schmuckmedaillons. Inagural-Diss. Berlin.
Bapst, G. 1887a. Les fouilles de Siverskaia (Caucase). Gazette archéologique 5—6, 116—123.
Bapst, G. 1887b. Les fouilles de Siverskaia (Caucase) (Suite). Coupe en argent doré. Gazette archéologique 12, 147—149.
Baratte, F. 2002. East and West: A Central Asian Silver Hoard from the Parthian Era London: Melisende.
Bartsiokas et al. 2015: Bartsiokas, A., Arsuagab, J.L, Santos, E., Algaba, M., Gymez-Olivenciad, A. 2015. The lameness of King Philip II and Royal Tomb I at Vergina, Macedonia. PNAS 112(32), 9844—9848.
Bidzilya, V.I., Polin, S.V. 2012. Skifskiy tsarskiy kurgan Gaymanova Mogila (Scythian Royal Burial mound Gaymanova Mogila). Kiev: Skif (in Russian).
Boardman, J. 1994. The Diffusion of Classical Art in Antiquity. London: Thames and Hudson.
Bonivento Pupino, G. 1994. Il dibattito. In: Magna Grecia etruschi fenici. Atti del 33. Convegno di Studi sulla Magna Graecia, Taranto, 8—13 ottobre 1993. Tarent: Istituto per la storia e l'archeologia della magna Grecia, 335—336.
Bonivento Pupino, G. 1995. L'emblema in argento da Taranto al British Museum. Rendiconti della Accademia di Archeologia Lettere e Belle Arti. Nuova Serie. Vol. LXV, 131—155.
Borza, E.N., Palagia, O. 2008. The Chronology of the Macedonian Royal Tombs at Vergina. JDI 122, 81—126.
Byvank-Qarles van Ufford, L. 1989. A propos de l'orfèvrerie thrace. BABesch 64, 205-219.
Byvank-Qarles van Ufford, L. 1990. A propos du trésor de Rogosen. BABesch 65, 51—72.
Carter, M.L. 2015. Arts of the Hellenized East, Precious Metalwork and Gems of the Pre-Islamic Era. London: Thames and Hudson.
Cat. Basel 2007: Zanoni, I. (Hrsg.). Die alten Zivilisationen Bulgariens. Das Gold der Thraker. Basel: Antikenmuseum und Sammlung Ludwig.
Cat. Bonn 1997: Barkova, L., Kalasnik, Ju. (Hrsg.). Zwei Gesichter der Eremitage. Die Skythen und ihr Gold. Bonn: Ostfildern-Ruit bei Stuttgart Hatje.
Cat. Bonn 2004: Echt, R. (Hrsg.). Die Thraker. Das goldene Reich des Orpheus. Bonn: Kunst und Ausstellungshalle der Bundesrepublik Deutschland.
Cat. Cologne 1979: Gold der Thraker. Archäologische Schätze aus Bulgarien. Mainz: von Zabern.
Cat. Hanover 1994: Vokotopoulou, I. (Hrsg.). Makedonen die Griechen des Nordens. Athens: Kultusministerium.
Cat. Malibu 2007: Trofimova, A. (ed.). Greeks on the Black Sea: Ancient Art from the Hermitage. Los Angeles: J. Paul Getty Museum.
Cat. Milan 1984: de Juliis, E.H. (ed.). Gli ori di Taranto in età ellenistica. Milan: A. Mondadori.
Cat. Milan 1995: Curletti, M.G. (ed.). Tesori delle Steppe. Cimmeri, Sciti, Sarmati, Unni, Avari e Cazari. Milan: Galleria Ottavo Piano, La Rinascente.
Cat. Montreal 1987: Gold of the Thracian Horsemen. Treasures from Bulgaria. Montreal: Editions de l'Homme.
Cat. Moscow 2002: Zhuravlev, D.V. (ed.). Na krayu oykumeny. Greki i varvary na severnom beregu Ponta Evksinskogo (At the edge of the oikumene. Greeks and Barbarians on the North Coast of Pontus Euxine). Moscow: State Historical Museum (in Russian).
Cat. Oxford 2011: Galanakis, Y. (ed.). Heracles to Alexander the Great. Treasures from the Royal Capital of Macedon, a Hellenic Kingdom in the Age of Democracy. Oxford: Ashmolean Museum.
Cat. Paris 2006: Fol, V. (ed.). L'or des Thraces. Trésors de Bulgarie. Musée Jacquemart-André. Gand: Snoeck.
Cat. Paris 2015. Martinez, J.-L. (ed.). L'épopée des rois thraces — Des guerres médiques aux invasions celtes, 479—278 av. J.-C. Paris: Somogy.
Cat. Saint Louis 1998: Marazov, I. (ed.). Ancient Gold: The Wealth of the Thracians. Treasures from the Republic of Bulgaria. New York: Harry N. Abrams.
Cat. San Antonio 1999: Reeder, E.D. (ed.). Scythian Gold. Treasures from Ancient Ukraine. New York: Harry Abrams in association with the Walters Art Gallery and the San Antonio Museum of Art.
Cat. St. Petersburg 2004: Piotrovskiy, M.B. (ed.). Iran v Ermitazhe, Formirovanie kollektriy (Iran in the Hermitage. The Formation of the Collections). Saint Petersburg: Slaviya (in Russian).
Cat. Thessaloniki 1997: Greek Jewellery. 6000 Years of Tradition. Athens: Archaeological Receipts Fund.
Cat. Toledo 1977: Oliver, A.Jr. Silver for the Gods. 800 Years of Greek and Roman Silver. Toledo: Toledo Museum of Art.
Cat. Trieste 2002: Giumlia-Mair, A., Rubinich, M. (eds.). Le arti di Efesto. Capolavori in metallo dalla Magna Grecia. Trieste: Silvana Editoriale.
Cat. Vienna 1993: Seipel, W. (Hrsg.). Gold aus Kiew. 170 Meisterwerke aus der Schatzkammer der Ukraine. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum.
Cat. Zurich 1993: Karabelnik, M. (Hrsg.). Aus den Schatzkammern Eurasiens. Zurich: Kunsthaus.
Conze, A. 1884. Goldschmuck kleinasiatischer Fundorte. AZ 42, 89—94.
Courby, F. 1922. Les vases Grecs à reliefs. Paris: E. de Boccard.
Dana, D. 2015. Inscriptions. In: Valeva, J., Nankov, E., Graninger, D. (eds.). A Companion to Ancient Thrace. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 243—264.
de.pinterest.com: 1: Didyma, Temple of Apollo. Available at: https://de.pinterest.com/pin/454582156111479719/ (accessed 01.10.2022).
Delbrueck, R. 1912. Italien: Archäologische Funde im Jahre 1911. AA, 270—322.
Delev, P. 2015. Thrace from the Assassination of Kotys I to Koroupedion (360—281 BCE). In: Valeva, J., Nankov, E., Graninger, D. (eds.). A Companion to Ancient Thrace. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 48—58.
Delides, G.S. 2016. The Royal Tombs at Vergina Macedonia, Greece, Revisited. A Forensic Review. International Journal of Forensic Science and Pathology 4 (4), 234—239.
deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de: 1: Palmettenantefix von der Traufsima des Leonidaions. Available at: https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/item/4CJ2UPTS5UUWVSJG4VU73AQZ6RWFRLYC (accessed 01.10.2022).
deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de: 2: Palmettenantefix. Available at: https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/item/POMPHGZF5TPMM45FGFDA3NM7LP6VCA2F (accessed 01.10.2022).
Dimitrov, D.P. 1960. Gradoustroistvo i arkhitektura na trakiiskiya grad Sevtopolis (Town planning and architecture of the Thracian city of Seuthopolis). Arkheologiya (Archaeology Sofia) 1, 3—15 (in Bulgarian).
Dimitrova, D. 2006. Annotations to the Catalogue. In: Fol, V., Stoev, A., Stoeva, P., Kitov, G., Dimitrova, D. The Thracian Cosmos. The Sacred Realm of Kings. Sofia: Institute of Thracology of Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 96—111.
Dimitrova, D. 2015. Гробницата на Севт III в могила Голяма Косматка / The Tomb of King Seuthes III in Golyama Kosmatka Tumulus. Sofia: Aros.
Firsov, K.B. 2010. Gosudarstvennyy istoricheskiy muzey. Pamyatniki skifo-sarmatskogo vremeni i rannego srednevekov'ya iz Prikuban'ya (State Historical Museum. Monuments of the Scythian-Sarmatian period and the early Middle Ages from the Kuban region). In: Bongard-Levin, G.M., Kuznetsov, V.D. (eds.). Antichnoe nasledie Kubani (Ancient Heritage of Kuban). Vol. III. Moscow: Nauka, 328—352 (in Russian).
Fol, A. 1990. Der Schatzfund von Rogozen. Zum Hellenismus in Südosteuropa. In: International Congress of Classical Archaeology (Hrsg.). Akten des XIII. Intern. Kongresses für klassische Archäologie Berlin 1988. Mainz: von Zabern, 195—205.
Fol, A., Tsvetkov, B., Mihailov, G., Venedikov, I., Marazov, I. 1989. The Rogozen Treasure. Sofia: Publishing House of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences.
Frazer, A. 1990. The Propylon of Ptolemy II. Princeton: Princeton University Press (Samothrace 10).
Galanina, L., Grach, N. 1986. The Scythian Art. Leningrad: Aurora.
Gehrig, U. 1977. Antiken Museum. Zwei neue hellenistische Silberarbeiten im Antikenmuseum. JbBerlMus 19, 5—12.
Gill, W.J.D. 2008. Inscribed Silver Plate from Tomb II at Vergina: Chronological Implications. Hesperia 77, 335—358.
Ginev, G. 1983. Sakrovisheto ot Kralevo (Treasure from Kralevo). Sofia: Bulgarian artist (in Bulgarian).
Guzzo, P.G. 2003. A Group of Hellenistic Silver Objects in the Metropolitan Museum. Metropolitan Museum Journal 38, 45—94.
Haddad, N.A. 2015. Critical Assessment of the Barrel Vault. Geometry and Structure of the Oldest Macedonian Tomb of Eurydice in Vergina. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 15.2, 143—62.
Hatzopoulos, M.B. 2008. The Burial of the Dead (at Vergina) or the Unending Controversy on the identity of the Occupants of Tomb II. Tekmeria 9, 91—118.
Hausmann, U. 1981. Reliefmedallion Heracles und Hesperide. In: Mallwitz, A. (Hrsg.). X. Bericht über die Ausgrabungen in Olympia. Berlin: de Gruyter, 209—227.
Hausmann, U. 1995. Aphrodite und Adonis. Eirene XXXI. In honorem Jan Bouzek, 88—97.
Inkova et al. 1994: Inkova, V., Tsaneva, Sv., Draganova, K. 1994. Prinos kum izsledvaneto na fiala No. 4 ot Rogozenskoto sukrovishte (Contribution to the Study of the Phiale No. 4 from the Rogozen Treasure). Problemi na izkustvoto (Problems of Art) 4, 28—45 (in Bulgarian).
Ivanov, Т. 1956. Trakiyski mogilni pogrebeniya v Odesos i okolnosta mu prez rannoellinistichekata epokha (Thracian tumular burials in Odessos and its surroundings of the Early Hellenistic period). Izvestiya na Varnenskoto arkheologicheskoto druzhestvo (Reports of the Varna Archaeological Society) Х, 87—109 (in Bulgarian).
Jeppesen, K. 2002. The Superstructure. A comparative analysis of the architectural, sculptural, and literary evidence. Aarhus: Jutland Archaeological Society Publications (The Maussolleion at Halikarnassos 5).
Kaba, H. 2016. Being Rich in Life and Death. Gold and Silver Finds from a 4th Century Tomb in Soloi. In: Summerer, L., Kaba, H. (eds.). The Northern Face of Cyprus. New Studies in Cypriot Archaeology and Art History. Istanbul: Yayinlari, 225—242.
Kalashnik, Yu.P. 2004. Greek Gold. From the Treasure Rooms of the Hermitage. Zwolle: Waanders Publishers.
Kalashnik, Yu.P. 2014. Grecheskoe zoloto v sobranii Ermitazha (Greek Gold in the Collection of the Hermitage). Saint Petersburg: State Hermitage (in Russian).
Kan §ahin, G., Christof, E., Lafli, E. 2019. A Bronze Mirror with Aphrodite and Eros from Nicomedia. In: Uluslararasi Orhan Gazi ve Kocaeli Tarihi-Kültürü Sempozyumu — V, Bildirileri International Symposium on Orhan Gazi and History-Culture of Kocaeli-V. Proceedings. Vol. 1. Kocaeli: Kocaeli Büyük§ehir Belediyesi, 125—132.
khm.at: 1: Gesimsblock mit Lotos-Palmettenfries. Available at: www.khm.at/de/object/62af24ffc4/ (accessed 01.10.2022).
Kitov, G. 2006a. Panagyurskoto sakrovishche (Panagyurishte Treasure). Varna: Slavena (in Bulgarian).
Kitov, G. 2006b. The Valley of the Thracian Kings". In: Fol, V., Stoev, A., Stoeva, P., Kitov, G., Dimitrova, D. The Thracian Cosmos. The Sacred Realm of Kings. Sofia: Institute of Thracology of Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 40—95.
Kottaridi, A. 2006. Couleur et sens: l'emploi de la couleur dans la tombe de la reine Eurydice. In: Guimier-Sorbes, A.-M., Hatzopoulos, M.B., Morizot, Y. (eds.). Rois, cites, necropoles: institutions, rites et monuments en Macedoine. Athens: Centre de recherches de l'antiquité grecque et romaine, 155—168 (Meletemata 45).
Kottaridi, A. 2011. The Palace of Aegae. In: Lane Fox, R.J. (ed.). Brill's Companion to Ancient Macedon. Studies in the Archaeology and History of Macedon, 650 B.C. —300 A.D. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 297—333.
Kull, B. 1997. Orient und Okzident. Aspekte der Datierung und Deutung des Hortes von Rogozen. In: Becker, C. et al. (Hrsg.). Chronos. Beiträge zur prähistorischen Archäologie zwischen Nord- und Südosteuropa. Festschrift für Bernhard Hänsel. Rahden/Westf: Verlag Marie Leidorf, 689—710 (Internationale Archäologie; Studia honoraria 1).
Künzl, E. 1979. Zum hellenistischen Silber des Grabes von Es Soumâa bei El Khroub. In: Horn, H.G., Rüger, C.B. (Hrsg.). Die Numider. Reiter und Könige nördlich der Sahara. Cologne: Rheinland-Verlag; Bonn: In Kommission bei R. Habelt, 287—304.
Lafli, E., Çetingôz, A. 2021. A Bronze Mirror with Aphrodite and Eros from Nicomedia in Bithynia (northwestern Turkey)Cuadernos de arquelogha de la Universidad de Navarra 29, 329—340. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15581/012.29.014.
Lafli, E., Kan §ahin, G. 2021. A Bronze Mirror with Aphrodite and Eros from Nicomedia in Bithynia (Northwestern Turkey). In: Lafli, E. (ed.). Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Bronzes from Anatolia and Neighbouring Regions. Oxford: BAR Publishing, 67—72 (BAR International Ser. 3038).
Loukopoulou, L.D. 2008. Les inscriptions des trésors nord-balkaniques. In: Loukopoulou, L.D., Psoma, S. Thrakika Zetemata. I. Athens: KERA, 139—169 (Ms^sx^axa 58).
louvre.fr: 1: Louvre. Available at: http://www.louvre.fr/en/oeuvre-notices/fragments-arsinoeion-samothrace-marble-coping-and-part-parapet (accessed 01.10.2022).
Luschey, H. 1939. Die Phiale. Bleicherode am Harz: Nieft.
Manassero, N. 2007. Confronting Two Rhytons' Settings: The Panagyurishte and the "Black Sea" Treasures. In: Marazov, I. (ed.). Mif. Obredut (Myth. The rite). Iss. 12. Sofiya: Novbulgarski universitet, 115—139.
Mantsevich, A.P. 1987. Kurgan Solokha. Publikatsiya opdnoy kollektsii (Solokha Burial mound. Publication of one Collection). Leningrad: Iskusstvo (in Russian).
Manzewitsch, A. 1932. Ein Grabfund aus Chersonnes. Verhandlungen der Akademie für Geschichte der Materiellen Kultur. II.1. Leningrad: Druckerei OGIZ "Iw. Fedorow", 7—13.
Marazov, I. 1978. Ritonite v drevna Trakiya (Rhyta in Ancient Thrace). Sofia: Bulgarian artist (in Bulgarian).
Marazov, I. 1981. Trakiiskiyat tip nachelnitsi (The Thracian type of Frontlets). Problemi na izkustvoto (Problems of Art) 14 (1), 19—27 (in Bulgarian).
Marazov, I. 1996. Rogozenskoto sakrovishche (Rogozen Treasure). Sofia: IK "Sekor" (in Bulgarian).
Marshall, F.H. 1911. Catalogue of the Jewellery, Greek, Etruscan and Roman, in the Departments of Antiquities, British Museum. London: Printed by order of the Trustees.
Matz, F. 1956. Ein neuattisches Motiv und seine hellenistischen Voraussetzungen. Marburger Winckelmannsprogramm, 21—30.
Mayer, M. 1910. La coppa tarantina di argento dorato del Museo provinciale di Bari. Commissione provinciale di archeologia e storiapatria, Documenti e Monografie. Vol. IX. Bari: Vecchi; Trani.
Mc Credie, J.R., Roux, G., Shaw, S.M., Kurtich, J. 1992. The Rotunda of Arsinoe. Princeton: Princeton University Press (Samothrace VII).
Meetings Between Cultures in the Ancient Mediterranean. Bolletino di archeologia on line 1/2010. Volume speciale C/C10/4, 44—63.
Mintschev, A. 1983. Ein verschwundener thrakischer Schatz aus Kavarna und einigeBemerkungen über die Goldschmiedekunst Thrakiens im IV. —III. Jh. v.u.z. Pulpudeva. Semaines Philippopolitaines de l'Histoire et de la Culture Thrace, Plovdiv, 3—17 octobre 1980. 4. Sofia: Editions de l'Académie bulgare des sciences, 310—323.
Mozolevs'kiy, B.M. 1979. TovstaMogila (TovstaMogila). Kiev: Naukova dumka (in Ukranian).
Nachod, H. 1918. Die Silberschale aus Tarent in Bari. RM 33, 103—124.
Nankov, E. 2011. Berenike Bids Farewell to Seuthes III: The Silver-Gilt Scallop Shell Pyxis from the Golyama Kosmatka. Archaeologia Bulgarica XV.3, 1—22.
Nikolov et al. 1987: Nikolov, B., Mashov, S., Ivanov, P. 1987. Trakiisko sreburno sukrovishte ot Rogozen (Thracian Silver Treasure from Rogozen). Izvestiya na muzeite v Severozapadna Bulgariya (Reports of the Museums of North-Western Bulgaria) 12, 9—133 (in Bulgarian).
Odebesco, A. 1889/1900. Le trésor de Pétrossa. I. Leipzig: Hiersemann.
Ognenova, L., Stoyanov, T. 2005. The Chalkidian Helmets and the Origin of the North Thracian Ceremonial Armour. In: Rabadjiev, K., Milcheva, M. (eds.). Stephanos Arcaeologicos in honorem Professoris Ludmili Getov. Sofia: University Publishing House "St. Kliment Ohridski", 519—539 (Studia archaeologica Universitatis Serdicensis, Supplementum 4).
Ognenova-Marinova, L. 1987. Belezhki vurkhu fialata ot Rogozenskoto sukrovishte s motiv ot mita za Kherakül i Avge (Notes on the Phiale from the Rogozen Treasure with a Motif from the Myth of Heracles and Auge). Arkheologiya (Archaeology Sofia) 3, 47—54 (in Bulgarian).
Oliver, A.Jr. 1977. New Hellenistic Silver: Mirror, Emblem Dish and Spoons. JbBerlMus 19, 13—22.
Pfrommer, M. 1987a. Studien zu alexandrinischer und grossgriechischer Toreutik frühhellenistischer Zeit. Berlin: Gebr. Mann (Archäologische Forschungen 16).
Pfrommer, M. 1987b. Überlegungen zur Baugeschichte des Naiskos im Apollontempel zu Didyma. IstMitt 37, 145—185.
Pfrommer, M. 1990. Untersuchungen zur Chronologie früh- und hochhellenistischen Goldschmucks. Tübingen: E. Wasmuth (Istanbuler Forschungen 37).
Pfrommer, M. 1993. Metalwork from the Hellenized East. Malibu: J. Paul Getty Museum.
Pfrommer, M. 1999. Alexandria. Im Schatten der Pyramiden. Mainz: von Zabern.
Pierides, A. 1971. Jewellery in the Cyprus Museum. Nicosia: Department of antiquities.
Platz-Horster, G. 2003. Der Silberfund von Paterno. Jdl 118, 205—284.
Polin, S.V. 2014. Skifskiy Zolotobalkovskiy kurgannyy mogil'nik V—IV vv. do n.e. na Khersonshchine (Scythian Zolotaya Balka Tumular Cemetery of the 5th — 4th Centuries BCE in the Kherson Region). Kiev: Oleg Filyuk (Burial mounds of the Ukraine 3) (in Russian).
Polos'mak et al. 2011: Polos'mak, N.V., Bogdsanov, E.S., Tsevendorzh, D. 2011. Dvadtsatyy noin-ulinskiy kurgan (Noin-Ula Burial mound no. 20). Novosibirsk: Infolio (in Russian).
Praschniker, C., Theuer, M. 1979. Das Mausoleum von Belevi. Vienna: Österreichisches Archäologisches Institut (Forschungen in Ephesos 6).
Rehm, E. 2010. The Classification of Objects from the Black Sea Region Made or Influenced by the Achaemenids. In: Nieling, J., Rehm, E. (eds.). Achaemenid Impact in the Black Sea. Communication of Powers. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press, 161—194 (Black Sea Studies 11).
Reinsberg, C. 1980. Studien zur hellenistischen Toreutik. Die antiken Gipsabgüsse aus Memphis. Hildesheim: Gerstenberg (Hildesheimer ägyptologische Beiträge 9).
Rostovtzeff, M.I. 1918. Kurgannye nakhodki Orenburgskoy oblasti epokhi rannego i pozdnego ellinizma (Tumular Finds of the Orenburg region of the Early and Late Hellenistic Periods). Petrograd: State Archaeological Commission (Materials on Archaeology of Russia 37) (in Russian).
Rubensohn, O. 1911. Hellenistisches Silbergerät in antiken Gipsabgüssen. Berlin: K. Curtius.
Rumscheid, F. 1994. Untersuchungen zur kleinasiatischen Bauornamentik des Hellenismus. Mainz: von Zabern (Beiträge zur Erschließung hellenistischer und kaiserzeitlicher Skulptur und Architektur 14).
Saverkina, I.I. 2000. Roskoshnyye ser'gi v Ermitazhe i v drugikh muzeyakh (Luxurious earrings in the Hermitage and other museums). In: Solovyov, S.L. (ed.). Antichnoe Prichernomor'e. Sbornik statey po klassicheskoy arkheologii (Antique Black Sea Coast. A Collection of Articles on Classical Archaeology). Saint-Petersburg: State Hermitage, 7—23 (in Russian).
Scatozza Höricht, L.A. 2010. Kyme di Eolide e l'oro di Dioniso: Nuovo diadema dalla necropoli. AA 1, 105—123.
Schefold, K. 1938. Der skythische Tierstil in Südrussland. Eurasia Septentrionalis Antiqua XII, 1—78.
Schiltz, V. 1994. Die Skythen und andere Steppenvölker. Munich: C.H. Beck.
Schwarzmaier, A. 1997. Griechische Klappspiegel. Berlin: Gebr. Mann (AM Beih. 18).
Segall, B. 1965. Alexandria und Tarent. Eine tarentinische Fundgruppe des frühen Hellenismus. AA, 553—588.
Shefton, B. 1989. The Auge Bowl. In: Cook, B.F. (ed.). The Rogozen Treasure, Papers of the Anglo-Bulgarian Conference, 12March 1987. London: British Museum, 82—90.
Sideris, A. 2021. Metal Vases & Utensils in the Vassil Bojkov Collection. Vol. 2. Sofia: Thrace Foundation.
Sieveking, J. 1930. Bronzen, Terrakotten, Vasen der Sammlung Loeb. Munich: Buchholz.
Simon, E. 1960. Der Goldschatz von PanagjuriSte — eine Schöpfung der Alexanderzeit. Antike Kunst 3, 3—26.
Sparkes, B.A. 1996. The Red and the Black. Studies in Greek Pottery. London; New York: Routledge.
Stoyanov, T. 1991. Za interpretatsiyata na kanichka No. 155 ot Rogozenskoto sukrovishte (On the Interpretation of the Jug No. 155 from the Rogozen Treasure). Arkheologiya (Archaeology Sofia) 4, 16— 34 (in Bulgarian).
Stoyanov, T. 2003. Za proizkhoda i razvitieto na fialite s antropomorfna plastichna dekoratsiya (On the Origin and Development of Phialai with Anthropomorphic Plastic Decoration). In: Angelova, S. (ed.).
Sbornik v pamet na d-r P. Gorbanov (Collection of Articles in the Memory of Dr. P. Gorbanov). Sofia: University Publ. House „Saint Kliment of Ohrid", 87—104 (Studia Archaeologica, Suppl. 1) (in Bulgarian).
Stoyanov, T. 2005. The Balkan Group of White Lotus Jugs (or the so-called Derveni type jugs): some notes on the origin and distribution. In: Stoyanov, T., Tonkova, M., Preshlenov, H., Popov, H. (eds.). Heros Hephaistos. Studies in honorem Liubae Ognenova-Marinova. Veliko Tarnovo: Faber, 235—245.
Stoyanov, T. 2007. Late Classical and Early Hellenistic pottery imitations of metal tableware from Thrace. In: Iakovidou, A. (ed.). Thrace in the Greco-Roman World. Proceedings of the 10th International Congress of Thracology. Komotini-Alexandroupolis 18—23 October 2005. Athens: National Hellenic Research Foundation, 561—574.
Stoychev, R. 2012. Tekhniki za pozlata na metalni sudove ot Severozapadna Bulgariya (IV—III v. pr. Khr.) (Techniques for Gilding Metal Vessels from Northwestern Bulgaria (4th — 3rd Centuries BCE)). Arkheologiya (Archaeology Sofia) 4, 91—98 (in Bulgarian). Strong, D.E. 1966. Greek and Roman Gold and Silver Plate. London: Methuen.
Tacheva, M. 1986. Problemi i stanovishta po istoricheskata interpretatsiya na Rogozenskoto sukrovishte (Problems and Opinions on the Historical Interpretation of the Rogozen Treasure). Istoricheski Pregled (Historical Review) 12, 15—30 (in Bulgarian).
Tacheva, M. 1987. Arkheologicheski danni za datirane na Rogozenskoto sukrovishte. Problemi i stanovishta (Archaeological Grounds for dating of the Rogozen Treasure. Issues and Opinions). Arkheologiya (Archaeology Sofia) 4, 1—11 (in Bulgarian).
Tatcheva, M. 1990. Once Again About the "Unusual Phiale" from Rogozen. Bulgarian Historical Review 1, 72—73.
Tatcheva, M., Valtchinova, G. 1998. Le trésor de Rogozen: une nouvelle publication: Ivan Marazov, The Rogozen Treasure. Dialogues d'histoire ancienne 24.2, 271—278.
Theodossiev, N. 2000. North-Western Thrace from the Fifth to the First Century BC. Oxford: Archaeopress (BAR Intern. Ser. 859).
Tonkova, M. 2010. Les parures d'harnachement en or de Thrace et l'orfèvrerie de la haute époque hellénistique. Roma 2008. International Congress of Classical Archaeology.
Torbov, N. 2005. Mogilanskata mogila vav Vratsa (Mogilanska Mogila in Vratsa). Vratsa: Mayobo (in Bulgarian).
Torbov, N. 2015. Mogilanskata mogila vav Vratsa. Katalog (Mogilanska Mogila in Vratsa. Catalogue).
Vratsa: Mikrotest OOD (in Bulgarian). Treister, M. 1997. Concerning the Jewellery Items from the Burial Mound at Nogaichik. ACSS 4.2, 122—157. Treister, M. 1999a. Some Classical Subjects on Sarmatian Phalerae (to the origin of phalerae. In:
Tsetskhladze, G.R. (ed.). Ancient Greeks. West and East. Leiden; Boston; Cologne: Brill, 567—605. Treister, M.Y. 1999b. The Workshop of the Gorytos and Scabard Overlays. In: Reeder, E. (ed.). Scythian Gold. Treasures from Ancient Ukraine. New York: Harry Abrams in association with the Walters Art Gallery and the San Antonio Museum of Art, 71—81.
Treister, M. 2002. Grecia settentrionale e il Regno del Bosforo. Produzione metallurgica come riflesso dei contatti nella seconda metà del IV secolo a.C. In: Giumlia-Mair, A., Rubinich, M. (eds.). Le arti di Efesto. Capolavori in metallo dalla Magna Grecia. Trieste: Silvana Editoriale, 63—67. Treister, M. 2003. Metal Vessels from Zelenskaya Gora Barrow and Related Finds from Karagodeuashkh. AWE 2.1, 51—77.
Treister, M.Yu. 2006. Garnitur ukrasheniy iz pogrebeniya No. 1 Starshego Trekhbratnego kurgana (Jewelry set from burial No. 1 of the Elder Trekhbratny mound). In: Solovyov, S.L. (ed.). Greki i varvary na Bospore Kimmeriyskom v VII—I vv. do n. e. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii, Taman ', Rossiya 9— 16 oktyabrya 2000 (Greeks and Barbarians of the Cimmerian Bosporus in the 7th —1st Centuries BCE. Materials of the International Conference, Taman, Russia October 9—16, 2000). Saint Petersburg: State Hermitage, 164—190 (in Russian).
Treister, M. 2007. A Set of Jewellery from the Burial No.1 of the Elder Three Brothers barrow. In: Solovyov, S.L. (ed.). Greeks and Natives in the Cimmerian Bosporus (7th — 1st Centuries BCE). Papers of the International Conference, Taman, Russia, 9—16 October 2000. Oxford: Archaeopress, 128—144 (BAR Intern. Ser. 1729).
Treister, M.Yu. 2008. Izdeliya iz bronzy, kosti i ukrasheniya (Items from bronze, bones and jewelry). In: Treister, M.Yu. (ed.). Trekhbratnie kurgany. Kurgannaya gruppa vtoroy poloviny IV—III vv. do n. e. v Vostochnom Krymu (Three-Brothers Burial mounds. Kurgan Group of the second half of the 4th — 3rd Centuries BCE in the Eastern Crimea). Simferopol; Bonn: Universum, 105—122 (in Russian).
Treister, M.Yu. 2009a. Bronzovyy nagrudnik pantsirya s izobrazheniyem golovy Meduzy iz kurgana No. 6/1914—1915 u st. Yelizavetinskoy v Prikuban'ye (Bronze breastplate with a depiction of the head of Medusa from barrow No. 6/1914-1915 near St. Elizabethan in the Kuban region). Bosporskie issledovaniya (Bosporan Studies) XXI, 120—134 (in Russian).
Treister, M. 2009b. Silver phialai from the Prokhorovka Burial-Mound No. 1. ACSS 15, 95—135.
Treister, M.Yu. 2010. O khronologii nekotorykh pogrebal'nykh kompleksov iz raskopok D.V. Kareyshi i A.B. Ashika 1834—1835 gg. (On the chronology of some burial complexes from the excavations of D.V. Kareisha and A.B. Ashik 1834—1835). In: Tunkina, I.V. (ed.). Paul Du Brux. Sobranie sochineniy /Paul Du Brux. Oeuvres. T. 1. Saint Petersburg: Kolo, 589—601 (in Russian).
Treister, M.Yu. 2012. Sosudy iz dragotsennykh metallov akhemenidskogo kruga iz Yuzhnogo PriuraTya (Vessels of precious Metals of the Achaemenid Circle from the Southern Urals). In: M.Yu. Treister, L.T. Yablonskiy (eds.). Viyaniya akhemenidskoy kul'tury v Yuzhnom Priural'e (V—III vv. do n.e.) (Influences of the Achaemenid Culture in the Southern Urals (5th—3rd Centuries BCE)). Vol. 1. Moscow: Taus, 50—87 (in Russian).
Treister, M. 2016. On the Find of a Phalera made from the Medallion of a Hellenistic Cup in Barrow No. 20 of the Noin-Ula Burial-ground (Northern Mongolia). ACSS 22.2, 55—95.
Treister et al. 2012: Treister, M.Yu., Shemakhanskaya, M.S., Yablonskiy, L.T. 2012. Sosudy iz dragotsennykh metallov akhemenidskogo kruga iz Yuzhnogo Priural'ya (Vessels made of precious metals of the Achaemenid circle from the Southern Urals). In: Treister, M.Yu, Yablonskiy, L.T. (eds.). Vliyaniya akhemenidskoy kul'tury v Yuzhnom Priural'e (V—III vv. do n.e.) (Influences of the Achaemenid Culture in the Southern Urals (5th — 3rd Centuries BCE)). Vol. 2. Moscow: Taus, 65—76 (in Russian).
Tsigarida, B. 2006. Gold Diadems from the Cemetery of Ancient Pydna. In: Nicolini, G. (ed.). Les Ors des mondes Grec et "Barbare". Paris: Picard, 153—163.
Valeva, J. 2008. Gold and Silver Vessels from Ancient Thrace, II, Rhyta. Bulletin of MihoMuseum 7/8, 9—136.
Venedikov, I. 1961. Panagyurskoto zlatno sakrovishche (Panagyurishte Gold Treasure). Sofia: Bulgarian artist (in Bulgarian).
Venedikov, I., Gerassimov, T. 1973. Thrakische Kunst. Vienna, Munich: Schroll.
von Bothmer, D. 1984. A Greek and Roman Treasury. The Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin, XLII.1. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
von Prittwitz und Gaffron, H.-H. 1999. Die andere Seite der Einsichtigkeit. In: Bol, P.C. (Hrsg.). Hellenistische Gruppen. Gedenkschrift für Andreas Linfert. Mainz: von Zabern, 181—186.
Walters, H.B. 1921. Catalogue of the Silver Plate (Greek, Etruscan and Roman) in the British Museum. London: Printed by Order of the Trustees.
Webster, T.B.L. 1995. Monuments illustrating New Comedy.. BICS Suppl. 50. 3rd ed. rev. and enlarged by J.R. Green and A. Seeberg. London: Institute of Classical Studies; University of London School of Advanced Study.
Williams, D. 1996. The Kyme Treasure. In: Calinescu, A. (ed.). Ancient Jewelry and Archaeology. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 117—129.
Williams, D. 1998. Identifying Greek Jewellers. In: Williams, D. (ed.). The Art of the Greek Goldsmith. London: British Museum Press, 99—104.
Williams, D., Ogden, J. 1994. Greek Gold. Jewellery of the Classical World. London: British Museum Press.
Williams, D., Ogden, J. 1995. Grecheskoe zoloto. Yuvelirnoe iskusstvo klassicheskoy epokhi V—IVveka do n.e. (Greek Gold. Jewelry art of the Classical Era 5th — 4th Centuries BCE). Saint Petersburg: AO Slaviya (in Russian).
Winter, F. 2006. Studies in Hellenistic Architecture. Toronto; Buffalo; London: University of Toronto Press.
Wuilleumier, P. 1930. Tresor de Tarente. Paris: E. Leroux.
Wuilleumier, P. 1968. Tarente des origines à la conquête romaine. Paris: E. de Boccard (Bibliothèque des écoles françaises d'Athènes et de Rome 148).
Zazoff, P. 1998. Ein thrakischer Heracles: Zur Phiale von Rogozen. In: Fol, A., Goceva, Z., Jordanov, K., Porozhanov, K. (eds.). Studia in honorem Christo M. Danov. Sofia: Academia Litterarum Bulgarica, 89— 95 (Thracia 12).
Zazoff, P. 2011. Ein thrakischer Heracles: Zur Phiale von Rogozen. In: Popov, D. et al. (eds.). In memoriam Ivani Venedikov. Sofia: Institute of Thracology, 327—331 (Thracia 19).
Zhuravlev et al. 2014: Zhuravlev, D.V., Novikova, E.Yu., Shemakhanskaya, M.S. 2014. Yuvelirnye izdeliya iz kurgana Kul'-Oba v sobranii Istoricheskogo muzeya (Items of Jewellery from the Kul-Oba Burial mound in the Collection of the State Historical Museum). Moscow: State Historical Museum (in Russian).
Zimi, E. 2011. Late Classical and Hellenistic Silver Plate from Macedonia. Oxford Monographs on Classical Archaeology. Oxford: University Press.
Züchner, W. 1942. Griechische Klappspiegel. Berlin: De Gruyter (14. Ergh. Jdl.).

Еще

Статья научная