A case of chronic maxillary sinusitis in a late Neanderthal population of the Altai mountains
Автор: Zubova A.V., Kulkov A.M., Pikhur O.L., Moiseyev V.G., Kolobova K.A., Markin S.V.
Журнал: Archaeology, Ethnology & Anthropology of Eurasia @journal-aeae-en
Рубрика: Anthropology and paleogenetics
Статья в выпуске: 3 т.50, 2022 года.
Бесплатный доступ
We describe a likely case of chronic maxillary sinusitis (CMS) in a Neanderthal skeletal sample from Chagyrskaya Cave, in the Altai Mountains. Signs of CMS were recorded in the Chagyrskaya 57 specimen, which is a fragment of a left maxilla. Alveoli of the upper fi rst molar are partially preserved, and so are the second and third upper molars, with adjacent parts of the walls, and the fl oor of the maxillary sinus. The fragment was found in layer 6b, dating to 53,100–51,100 BP. We analyze the factors that had caused the development of the disease, and assess its etiology. In the 3D-model, generated by computed microtomography, and in the original specimen, porotic changes were registered, situated at the fracture line of the alveoli of M1, lost post-mortem, and near the vestibular roots of both preserved molars. Also, there were isolated bone spicules, 1.0–2.6 mm in size. These signs indicate incipient CMS, evidently caused by chronic periodontal disease combined with a deep alveolar recess of the maxillary sinus. As the periodontal gap expanded, several small nutrient foramina, piercing the bottom of the sinus, merged. As a result, several oro-antral channels formed, whereupon the infection spread into the maxillary sinus. Since the deep alveolar recess is observed in the vast majority of Neanderthal crania with published images or reconstructed maxillary cavities, it can be assumed that Neanderthals were predisposed to odontogenic CMS.
Chronic maxillary sinusitis, Neanderthals, Chagyrskaya Cave, paleopathology, archaeology, Middle Paleolithic
Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/145146794
IDR: 145146794 | DOI: 10.17746/1563-0110.2022.50.3.131-139
Список литературы A case of chronic maxillary sinusitis in a late Neanderthal population of the Altai mountains
- Abrahams J.J., Glassberg R.M. 1996 Dental disease: A frequently unrecognized cause of maxillary sinus abnormalities? American Journal of Roentgenology, vol. 166: 1219-1223.
- Arefieva N.A., Vishnyakov V.V., Ivanchenko O.A., Karpishchenko S.A., Kiselev A.B., Kozlov V.S., Kozlov R.S., Kosyakov S.Y., Kochetkov P.A., Lopatin A.S., Nakatis Y.A., Otvagin I.V., Piskunov G.Z., Polyakov D.P., Turovsky A.B. 2014 Khronicheskiy rinosinusit: Patogenez, diagnostika i printsipy lecheniya (klinicheskiye rekomendatsii). Moscow: Prakt. meditsina.
- Baumann M., Plisson H., Rendu W., Maury S., Kolobova K., Krivoshapkin A. 2020 Neandertalian bone industry at Chagyrskaya cave (Altai, Russia). Quaternary International, vol. 559: 68-88.
- Biedlingmaier J.F., Whelan P., Zoarski G., Rothman M. 1996 Histopathology and CT analysis of partially resected middle turbinates. Laryngoscope, vol. 106: 102-104.
- Boocock P., Roberts C.A., Manchester K. 1995 Maxillary sinusitis in medieval Chichester, England. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 98: 483-495.
- Brook I. 2009 Sinusitis. Periodontology 2000, vol. 49: 126-139.
- Buck L., Stringer C.B., MacLarnon A., Rae T.C. 2019 Variation in paranasal pneumatisation between Mid-Late Pleistocene hominins. Bullétins et Mémoires de la Société d’Anthropologie de Paris. URL: https://doi.org/10.3166/bmsap-2019-0056
- Buskina A.V., Gerber V.K. 2000 K vorposu o klinicheskoy klassifi katsii khronicheskogo odontogennogo gaimorita. Vestnik otorinolaringologii, No. 2: 20-22.
- Clarke N., Carey S. 1985 The aetiology of chronic periodontal disease: An alternative perspective. Journal of American Dental Association, No. 110: 689-691.
- Condemi S., Tardivo D., Bruno F., Ricci S., Giunti P., Longo L. 2012 A case of osteolithic lesion on an Italian Neanderthal jaw. Comptes Rendus Palevol, vol. 11: 79-83.
- Dean M.C., Rosas A., Estalrrich A., García-Tabernero A., Huguet R., Lalueza-Fox C., Bastir M., de la Rasilla M. 2013 Longstanding dental pathology in Neanderthals from El Sidrón (Asturias, Spain) with a probable familial basis. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 64 (6): 678-686.
- Emelyanova A.N. 2012 Klinicheskoye znacheniye variantov anatomicheskogo stroyeniya verkhnechelyustnoy i lobnoy pazukh: Cand. Sc. (Medicine) Dissertation. Kursk.
- Erdogan E., Fidan V., Giritli E. 2016 Radiologic imaging in chronic sinusitis. Different Aspects of Rhinosinusitis. URL: https://smjournals.com/ebooks/differentaspects-rhinosinusitis/chapters/DARS-16-05.pdf
- Georgalas C., Videler W., Freling N., Fokkens W. 2010 Global Osteitis Scoring Scale and chronic rhinosinusitis: A marker of revision surgery. Clinical Otolaryngology, vol. 35: 455-461.
- Glazyev I.E., Piskunov I.S. 2017 Anatomicheskiye predposylki razvitiya odontogennogo verkhnechelyustnogo sinusita. Rossiyskaya rinologiya, No. 3: 35-41.
- Hardy K., Buckley S., Collins M.J., Estalrrich A., Brothwell D., Copeland L., García-Tabernero A., GarcíaVargas S., de la Rasilla M., Lalueza-Fox C., Huguet R., Bastir M., Santamaría D., Madella M., Wilson J., Fernández Cortés A., Rosas A. 2012 Neanderthal medics? Evidence for food, cooking, and medicinal plants entrapped in dental calculus. Naturwissenschaften, Bd. 99: 617-626.
- Jenkins W.M., Kinane D.F. 1989 The ‘high risk’ group in periodontitis. British Dental Journal, No. 167: 168-171.
- Kolobova K.A., Chabai V.P., Shalagina A.V., Krajcarz M.T., Krajcarz M., Rendu W., Vasiliev S.K., Markin S.V., Krivoshapkin A.I. 2019 Exploitation of the natural environment by Neanderthals from Chagyrskaya Cave (Altai). Quartär, vol. 66: 7-31.
- Kolobova K., Roberts R., Chabai V., Jacobs Z., Krajcarz M., Shalagina A., Krivoshapkin A., Li B., Uthmeier T., Markin S., Morley M., O’Gorman K., Rudaya N., Talamo S., Viola B., Derevianko A. 2020 Archaeological evidence for two separate dispersals of Neanderthals into Southern Siberia. PNAS, vol. 117 (6): 2879-2885.
- Kolobova K.A., Shalagina A.V., Chabai V.P., Markin S.V., Krivoshapkin A.I. 2019 Signifi cation des technologies bifaciales au Paléolithique moyen des montagnes de l’Altaï. L’Anthropologie, vol. 123 (2): 276-288.
- Lewis M.E., Roberts C.A., Manchester K. 1995 Comparative study of the prevalence of maxillary sinusitis in Later Medieval urban and rural populations in Northern England. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 98: 497-506.
- López-Valverde A., López-Cristiá M., Prados-Frutos J.C., Gómez de Diego R., de Vicente J., Cutando A. 2012 Oral pathology in the Iberian Neanderthals. African Journal of Biotechnology, vol. 11 (23): 6359-6363.
- Lozano M., Subirà M.E., Aparicio J., Lorenzo C., Gómez-Merino G. 2013 Toothpicking and periodontal disease in a Neanderthal specimen from Cova Foradà site (Valencia, Spain). PLoS ONE, vol. 8 (10). URL: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0076852
- Mafee M.F., Tran B.H., Chapa A.R. 2006 Imaging of rhinosinusitis and its complications: Plain film, CT, and MRI. Clinical Reviews in Allergy and Immunology, vol. 30: 165-186.
- Mafessoni F., Grote S., de Filippo C., Slon V., Kolobova K.A., Viola B., Markin S.V., Chintalapati M., Peyregne S., Skov L., Skoglund P., Krivoshapkin A.I., Derevianko A.P., Meyer M., Kelso J., Peter B., Prüfer K., Pääbo S. 2020 A high-coverage Neandertal genome from Chagyrskaya Cave. PNAS, vol. 117 (26): 15133-15136.
- Mann A., Vandermeersch B., Delagnes A., Tournepiche J.-F. 2007 Human fossil remains from the Mousterian levels of Artenac (Charente). Comptes Rendus Palevol, vol. 6: 581-589.
- Momeni A.K., Roberts C.C., Chew F.S. 2008 Imaging of chronic and exotic sinonasal disease: Review. American Journal of Roentgenology, vol. 189 (suppl. 6): 35-45.
- Mukovozov I.N. 1982 Differentsialnaya diagnostika khirurgicheskikh zabolevaniy chelyustno-litsevoy oblasti. Leningrad: Meditsina.
- Ogden A. 2007 Advances in the palaeopathology of teeth and jaws. In Advances in Human Palaeopathology, R. Pinhasi, S. Mays (eds.). Сhichester: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, pp. 283-307.
- Panhuysen R., Coenen V., Bruintjes T. 1997 Chronic maxillary sinusitis in medieval Maastricht, the Netherlands. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, vol. 7: 610-614.
- Rae T.C., Koppe T., Stringer C.B. 2011 The Neanderthal face is not cold adapted. Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 60: 234-239.
- Roberts C.A. 2007 A bioarcheological study of maxillary sinusitis. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 133: 792-807.
- Schultz M. 2006 Results of the anatomical-palaeopathological investigations on the Neanderthal skeleton from the Kleine Feldhofer Grotte (1856) including the new discoveries from 1997/2000. Rheinische Ausgrabungen, vol. 58: 277-318.
- Schultz M., Schmidt-Schultz T.H. 2015 Paleopathology: Vestiges of pathological conditions in fossil human bone. In Handbook of Paleoanthropology. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 969-981.
- Schwartz J.H., Tattersall I. 1996 Signifi cance of some previously unrecognized apomorphies in the nasal region of Homo neanderthalensis. PNAS, vol. 93: 10852-10854.
- Sergi S., Ascenzi A., Bonucci E. 1972 Torus palatinus in the Neanderthal Circeo I skull. A histologic, microradiographic and electron microscopic investigation. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 36: 189-197.
- Shalagina A.V., Kharevich V.M., Mori S., Bomann M., Krivoshapkin A.I., Kolobova K.A. 2020 Rekonstruktsiya tekhnologicheskikh tsepochek proizvodstva bifasialnykh orudiy v industrii Chagyrskoy peshchery. Sibirskiye istoricheskiye issledovaniya, No. 3: 130-151.
- Sipkin A.M., Nikitin A.A., Lapshin V.P., Nikitin D.A., Chukumov R.M., Kryazhinova I.A. 2013 Verkhnechelyustnoy sinusit: Sovremenniy vzglyad na diagnostiku, lecheniye i reabilitatsiyu. Almanakh klinicheskoy meditsiny, No. 28: 82-87.
- Skov L., Peyrégne S., Popli D., Lasi L.M.N., Devièse T., Slon V., Zavala E.I., Hajdinjak M., Sümer A.P., Grote S., Bossom A.M., López D.H., Nickel B., Nagel S., Richter J., Essel E., Gansauge M., Schmidt A., Korlevic P., Comeskey D., Derevianko A.P., Kharevich A., Markin S.V., Talamo S., Douka K., Krajcarz M.T., Roberts R.G., Higham T., Viola B., Krivoshapkin A.I., Kolobova K.A., Kelso J., Meyer M., Pääbo S., Peter B.M. 2022 Genetic insights into the social organization of Neanderthals. Nature. (In press).
- Slavin R.G., Spector S.L., Bernstein I.L. 2005 The diagnosis and management of sinusitis: A practice parameter update. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, vol. 116: 13-47.
- Slon V., Mafessoni F., Vernot B., Filippo C. de, Grote S., Viola B., Hajdinjak M., Peyrégne S., Nagel S., Brown S., Douka K., Higham T., Kozlikin M.B., Shunkov M.V., Derevianko A.P., Kelso J., Meyer M., Prüfer K., Pääbo S. 2018 The genome of the offspring of a Neanderthal mother and a Denisovan father. Nature, vol. 561: 113-116.
- Snidvongs K., Earls P., Dalgorf D., Sacks R., Pratt E., Harvey R.J. 2014 Osteitis is a misnomer: A histopathology study in primary chronic rhinosinusitis. International Forum of Allergy and Rhinology, vol. 4 (5): 390-396.
- Spikins P., Needham A., Wright B., Dytham C., Gatta M., Hitchens G. 2019 Living to fight another day: The ecological and evolutionary significance of Neanderthal healthcare. Quaternary Science Review, vol. 217: 98-118.
- Sundman E.A., Kjellström A. 2013 Chronic maxillary sinusitis in medieval Sigtuna, Sweden: A study of sinus health and effects on bone preservation. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, vol. 23 (4): 447-458.
- Tattersall I. 2002 The case for saltational events in human evolution. The Speciation of Modern Homo sapiens: Proceedings of the British Academy, vol. 106: 49-59.
- Teul I., Lorkowski J., Lorkiewicz W., Nowakowski D. 2013 Sinusitis in people living in the medieval ages. In Neurobiology of Respiration: Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 133-138.
- Topić B., Raščić-Konjhodžić H., Sajko M.Č. 2012 Periodontal disease and dental caries from Krapina Neanderthal to contemporary man - skeletal studies. Acta Medica Academica, vol. 41 (2): 119-130.
- Vernot B., Zavala E.I., Gómez-Olivencia A., Jacobs Z., Slon V., Mafessoni F., Romagné F., Pearson A., Petr M., Sala N., Pablos A., Aranburu A., Castro J.M.B., de Carbonell E., Li B., Krajcarz M.T., Krivoshapkin A.I., Kolobova K.A., Kozlikin M.B., Shunkov M.V., Derevianko A.P., Viola B., Grote S., Essel E., Herráez D.L., Nagel S., Nickel B., Richter J., Schmidt A., Peter B., Kelso J., Roberts R.G., Arsuaga J.-L., Meyer M. 2021 Unearthing Neanderthal population history using nuclear and mitochondrial DNA from cave sediments. Science, vol. 372 (6542).
- Weyrich L.S., Duchene S., Soubrier J., Arriola L., Llamas B., Breen J., Morris A.G., Alt K.W., Caramelli D., Dresely V., Farrell M., Farrer A.G., Francken M., Gully N., Haak W., Hardy K., Harvati K., Held P., Holmes E.C., Kaidonis J., Lalueza-Fox C., de la Rasilla M., Rosas A., Semal P., Soltysiak A., Townsend G., Usai D., Wahl J., Huson D.H., Dobney K., Coope A. 2017 Neanderthal behavior, diet, and disease inferred from ancient DNA in dental calculus. Nature, vol. 544: 357-361.
- Zollikofer C.P.E., Ponce de Leon M., Schmitz R.W., Stringer C.B. 2008 New insights into Mid-Late Pleistocene fossil hominin paranasal sinus morphology. Anatomical Record, vol. 291: 1506-1516.
- Zubova A.V., Ananyeva N.I., Moiseyev V.G., Stulov I.K., Dmitrenko L.M., Obodovskiy A.V., Potrakhov N.N., Kulkov A.M., Andreev E.V. 2020 The use of computed tomography for the study of chronic maxillary sinusitis: Based on crania from the Pucará De Tilcara Fortress, Argentina. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 48 (3): 143-153.
- Zubova A.V., Moiseyev V.G., Ananyeva N.I., Stulov I.K., Andreev E.V. 2022 Chronic maxillary sinusitis recorded in archaeological samples: Geographical distribution and predisposing factors. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 50 (1): 147-157.