Quantitative changes in the anthropological status of middle school aged pupils over a two-year period
Автор: Benassi L., Blaevi I., Trajkovski B.
Журнал: Человек. Спорт. Медицина @hsm-susu
Рубрика: Физиология
Статья в выпуске: 1 т.18, 2018 года.
Бесплатный доступ
Aim. The research was conducted with the primary aim of determining the antropometric characteristics as well as motor and functional abilities of three groups of examinees over a two-year period of organized physical activity engagement. The secondary aims were to examine each group's nutritional status and their connection to the results achieved in the functional ability evaluation. Material and methods. In the total sample which consisted of 147 pupils, one group was engaged in martial arts (karate, wrestling, taekwondo and kick-boxing), the second group in team sports played with a ball (football, handball and basketball), while the third group was physically active only on Physical Education classes. Ten variables were used for the needs of the research, while to process the data, the Student's t-test for dependable samples, the discriminant analysis and the correlation analysis were used. Results. For all the three measurements, the results show the superiority of examinees - athletes compared to non-athletes. Engaging in team sports played with a ball at the age of 11 to 13 has a more positive influence on the analysed variables of the anthropological status than for peers who are non-athletes, but the same was not shown for athletes engaging in martial arts (p
Conditioning, sport, nutritional level, physical education, pupils
Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/147153396
IDR: 147153396 | DOI: 10.14529/hsm180101
Текст научной статьи Quantitative changes in the anthropological status of middle school aged pupils over a two-year period
Unlike the adult population, the estimate of the nutritional status according to children and adolescents' body mass index is determined regarding sex and chronological age and based on the percentile rank [30]. Due to its reliability and simple use, it is a good indicator of the childhood level of obesity [22] and it can be useful in the evaluation of malnutrition or excess body mass and obesity in children and adolescents [11]. In the last decades, the world's data [8] are also present in our country (The Croatian Health-Statistical Yearbook – with the equal criteria > 90 centiles for the single sex) and they clearly show an increase in the number of overnourished children and adolescents. A recent research [39] conducted on higher primary school grades' boys from Zagreb confirms the negative trend in the pupils' nutrition, according to which only 62 % of pupils were correctly nourished, while 43 % of 13-year-olds had excess body mass. According to Kopelman [20], the increase in the body mass index increases the possibility of health risks brought by some diseases primarily linked to diabetes type 2, hypertension, the coronary artery disease and brain stroke, the respiratory system, cancer, reproductive functions, liver and bladder diseases.
Conditioning represents a group of training procedures for the development and maintenance of the athlete's fuctional and motor abilities, as well as the athletes' morphological characteristics in line with a certain sport's requirements. It is, thus, an issue of an advancement in the aerobic ability and anaerobic capacity, the development of quantitative and qualitative motor abilities and the optimisation of athletes' morphological characteristics [28]. It is a generally known fact that the level of conditional readiness depends on age, sex, race, anthropometric measures and the intensity of training or exercising. Sports scientists have been trying for decades to find reliable ways of its evaluation on a various selection of populations. Resulting from these researches, today there are numerous methods to determine the state of the conditional readiness which have shown to be adequate for both the general population and athletes of different ages [17]. Researches have shown that exercising will be more regular and active in places where the conditions for it are fulfilled, primarily the material ones, and where exercising is supported and appreciated [4]. Moreover, the consulted literature shows that there were more authors dealing with the athletes' conditional readiness regarding the school-aged population. All of them found out that better results are accomplished by participators of programmes with more hours of exercising [1, 14], a higher intensity and level of general abilities [41], a normal-desirable nutritional status – value of the body mass index [37] and more adequate working conditions, especially regarding personell and material conditions [6, 10, 33, 49].
Article's aims and hypotheses
This article’s primary role is to determine the quantitative changes in boys’ kinanthropological characteristics during a period of two years occurring by the application of three different kine-siological operators. Its secondary role is to examine each group’s nutritional state and its connection to the results of the aerobic type functional abilities test.
H1.H 1 : There will be statistically significant changes in the kinanthropological characteristics for children – athletes engaging in team sports played with a ball when compared to children – athletes engaging in martial arts and children – non-athletes.
H2.H 1 : There will be a statistically significant connection between the body mass index and functional abilities for all three groups of examinees.
Material and Methods
Sample of examinees
Sample of variables
A set of 10 tests for measuring the anthropometric characteristics, motor abilities and functional abilities was used for the needs of this research [12] and the variables of the ITM centiles (CDC BMI).
-
■ To measure the anthropometric characteristics the following variables were used: height (ATV), body mass (ATT), forearm girth (AOP), while the body mass index (ITM) was worked out of the body height and body mass results and used as the indicator of the nutritional status of a person. The body mass index (ITM) was defined as: body mass (kg)/body height2 (m2) , while the calculated value for each pupil was corrected into centiles [9] according to the child's sex and chronological age (criterion: < 5 centiles = malnutrition, 5 – 85 centiles = normal body mass, 85 – 95 centiles = overweight, ≥ 95 centiles = = overnourishment (obesity)).
-
■ To measure the motor abilities the following variables were used: reverse training ground (MPN) – spatial coordination , standing long jump (MSD) – explosive power of lower extremities , pull up endurance (MIV) – static power of the arms and shoulders , hand tapping (MTR) – speed of simple movements , touch-toe with legs astride (MPR) – flexibility of the pelvis , trunk lifts (MPT) – repetitive power of the trunk.
-
■ To measure the functional abilities the variable of the 6 minute run (F6') was used.
The measurements were conducted in the first two weeks at the beginning of the school-year. The body mass was measured with a medical balance and all the examinees were without their footwear and wearing their sports clothes (a T-shirt and shorts). Body height was measured with the Martin anthropometer with the measuring exactness of 0.1 cm. The examinees were without their footwear with the position of the head in the so called Frankfurt horizontal plane.
Data processing methods
Entering and processing data was done by a computer programme for the statistical data processing named IBM SPSS Statistics Version 2.2. The basic descriptive parameters were calculated: arithmetic mean, standard deviation and the minimal and maximal value of results. The distribution normality was determined by the Kolmogorov- Smirnov test (K – S test). To analyse the changes in the two year period, i.e. to determine the statistically significant differences in the arithmetic means for the three groups of examinees the Student’s t-test for dependable samples was used. The discriminant analysis determined the differences among the three groups of examinees at the initial, transitive and final measurement. The level of correlation between the nutritional status results and the level of functional ability in the three masurements was determined by the correlation analysis. The set hypotheses are the results obtained by testings at the level of statistical significance p < 0.05.
Results
Table 1 shows the common results of the basic descriptive parameters for the three groups of examinees at the initial, transitive and final measurement. The Kolmogorov – Smirnov test determined the normality of distribution which showed that the results of distribution did not significantly depart from the normal. In the area of anthropometric characteristics, looking from the initial to the final measurement, pupils undergo an increase in the results of body height (ATV), body mass (ATT) and forearm girth (AOP), while an insignificant downfall is seen in the body mass index (ITM) at the transitive measurement to slightly grow again to the average result (Mean) of 0.17 centiles at the final measurement. Regarding motor and functional abilities, pupils made an advancement in all variables from the initial to the final measurement.
The Student's t-test results for dependable samples at the transitive measurement after a one-year period show that pupils engaging in martial arts (Table 2) achieve a quantitative advancement for all eleven variables. A statistically significant improvement of arithmetic mean was achieved for eight variables (ATV, ATT, AOP, ITM, MTR, MPN, MPT and F6'), while for three variables (MSD, MPR and MIV) there were no statistically significant differences.
Unlike pupils engaging in martial arts, those playing team sports with a ball achieved a negative move in the variable of body mass index
Table 1
Basic descriptive parameters of the whole sample at the initial, transitive and final measurement
Var./Per. |
N |
Mean |
Std. Dev. |
Min. |
Max. |
Skew. |
Kurt. |
K–S p |
ATV/i |
147 |
149.82 |
7.86 |
130.80 |
167.00 |
.16 |
–.42 |
.094 |
ATT/i |
147 |
44.97 |
13.70 |
26.00 |
95.00 |
1.60 |
2.85 |
.000 |
AOP/i |
147 |
22.07 |
2.50 |
17.50 |
30.20 |
.79 |
.59 |
.046 |
ITM/i |
147 |
61.01 |
31.49 |
5.00 |
95.00 |
–.45 |
–1.24 |
.000 |
MTR/i |
147 |
23.83 |
3.95 |
16.00 |
36.00 |
.42 |
.32 |
.005 |
MSD/i |
147 |
148.53 |
22.22 |
71.00 |
190.00 |
–.54 |
.50 |
.164 |
MPN/i |
147 |
18.09 |
5.29 |
10.38 |
37.80 |
1.13 |
1.33 |
.001 |
MPT/i |
147 |
31.50 |
7.30 |
6.00 |
57.00 |
–.14 |
1.68 |
.190 |
MPR/i |
147 |
39.61 |
10.47 |
6.00 |
63.00 |
–.34 |
.41 |
.098 |
MIV/i |
147 |
21.36 |
19.78 |
.00 |
85.00 |
1.03 |
.61 |
.000 |
F6'/i |
147 |
1065.61 |
204.28 |
611.00 |
1472.00 |
.05 |
–.71 |
.166 |
ATV/t |
147 |
156.49 |
8.63 |
134.60 |
177.00 |
.05 |
–.38 |
.197 |
ATT/t |
147 |
50.10 |
14.22 |
28.00 |
105.00 |
1.40 |
2.32 |
.000 |
AOP/t |
147 |
23.04 |
2.46 |
18.50 |
31.00 |
.63 |
.54 |
.160 |
ITM/t |
147 |
60.22 |
30.04 |
5.00 |
95.00 |
–.34 |
–1.30 |
.000 |
MTR/t |
147 |
26.64 |
3.74 |
17.00 |
39.00 |
.19 |
.76 |
.063 |
MSD/t |
147 |
152.80 |
24.06 |
76.00 |
213.00 |
–.22 |
–.03 |
.188 |
MPN/t |
147 |
15.99 |
4.33 |
9.59 |
38.40 |
1.79 |
5.82 |
.000 |
MPT/t |
147 |
34.84 |
8.09 |
13.00 |
59.00 |
–.13 |
.30 |
.194 |
MPR/t |
147 |
42.60 |
10.87 |
16.00 |
66.00 |
–.36 |
–.42 |
.033 |
MIV/t |
147 |
23.13 |
20.96 |
.00 |
100.00 |
1.08 |
1.09 |
.000 |
F6'/t |
147 |
1116.12 |
201.18 |
602.00 |
1506.00 |
–.13 |
–.77 |
.185 |
ATV/f |
147 |
163.76 |
9.46 |
140.00 |
185.70 |
–.07 |
–.34 |
.180 |
ATT/f |
147 |
56.90 |
16.25 |
31.00 |
120.00 |
1.40 |
2.84 |
.000 |
AOP/f |
147 |
23.97 |
2.67 |
18.80 |
34.00 |
.75 |
1.19 |
.189 |
ITM/f |
147 |
60.39 |
29.90 |
5.00 |
95.00 |
–.39 |
–1.20 |
.000 |
MTR/f |
147 |
28.59 |
4.02 |
17.00 |
39.00 |
–.05 |
.25 |
.005 |
MSD/f |
147 |
164.47 |
26.38 |
91.00 |
211.00 |
–.25 |
–.61 |
.192 |
MPN/f |
147 |
14.53 |
4.01 |
8.66 |
26.63 |
1.06 |
.68 |
.000 |
MPT/f |
147 |
38.40 |
7.64 |
12.00 |
67.00 |
–.45 |
2.63 |
.000 |
MPR/f |
147 |
44.64 |
12.88 |
4.00 |
75.00 |
–.48 |
.13 |
.003 |
MIV/f |
147 |
29.84 |
23.92 |
.00 |
102.00 |
.63 |
–.29 |
.003 |
F6'/f |
147 |
1176.61 |
228.63 |
626.00 |
1690.00 |
.05 |
–.59 |
.191 |
Note: Var. – variable / Per. – measurement period (i – initial, t – transitive, f – final); N – number of entities in the sample; Mean – arithmetic mean; Std. Dev. – standard deviation; Min. – minimal result; Max. – maximal result; Skew. – distribution curve; Kurt. – flattening of the distribution.
(ITM) after one year, but a statistically significant improvement in seven out of eleven variables (ATV, ATT, AOP, MTR, MPN, MPT and F6'). A positive move, yet not statistically significant, was recorded in three motor ability variables (MSD, MPR and MIV) (Table 2).
Table 2. shows the Student's t-test results for dependable samples of pupils who were not engaged in any sport, but were physically active only during Physical Education classes at school. After the one-year period they achieved statistically significant changes in nine variables (ATV, ATT, AOP, MTR, MSD, MPN, MPT, MPR and F6'). Advancement was recorded in the two remaining variables (ITM and MIV), but it was not statistically significant.
After the two-year monitoring period, examinees engaged in martial arts (Table 3) achieved a significant advancement in eight variables (ATV, ATT, AOP, MSD,MPN, MPR, MIV and F6'). In two motor abilities variables (MTR and MPT) the advancement was not significant, while in the variable for the evaluation of a person's nutritional status (ITM), a decline in the results compared to the transitive measurement was recorded.
In the same period (Table 3), examinees engaged in team sports played with a ball achieved a significant move in nine out of eleven variables (ATV, ATT, AOP, MTR, MSD, MPN, MPT, MIV and F6'). The changes were not significant, although a slight positive move was recorded, for the remaining two variables – evaluation
Table 2
T-test results for dependable samples between the initial and transitive measurement of examinees engaged in martial arts, team sports played with a ball and non-athletes
Martial arts |
Sports played with a ball |
Non-athletes |
|||||||
Var./Per. |
Mean |
N |
p < .05 |
Mean |
N |
p < .05 |
Mean |
N |
p < .05 |
ATV/i |
150.53 |
21 |
151.14 |
52 |
148.56 |
47 |
|||
ATV/t |
157.21 |
21 |
.000 |
157.85 |
52 |
.000 |
155.13 |
47 |
.000 |
ATT/i |
43.08 |
21 |
41.12 |
52 |
50.01 |
47 |
|||
ATT/t |
46.57 |
21 |
.000 |
46.73 |
52 |
.000 |
55.22 |
47 |
.000 |
AOP/i |
21.44 |
20 |
21.43 |
52 |
23.06 |
47 |
|||
AOP/t |
22.30 |
20 |
.001 |
22.61 |
52 |
.000 |
23.79 |
47 |
.000 |
ITM/i |
53.76 |
21 |
51.10 |
52 |
75.13 |
47 |
|||
ITM/t |
46.24 |
21 |
.006 |
52.19 |
52 |
.737 |
74.72 |
47 |
.774 |
MTR/i |
23.27 |
22 |
24.67 |
55 |
22.82 |
55 |
|||
MTR/t |
27.55 |
22 |
.000 |
26.73 |
55 |
.000 |
25.91 |
55 |
.000 |
MSD/i |
159.50 |
22 |
156.60 |
55 |
135.44 |
55 |
|||
MSD/t |
166.41 |
22 |
.102 |
159.47 |
55 |
.168 |
140.60 |
55 |
.015 |
MPN/i |
16.72 |
21 |
16.10 |
55 |
21.67 |
55 |
|||
MPN/t |
14.35 |
21 |
.006 |
14.39 |
55 |
.000 |
19.24 |
55 |
.000 |
MPT/i |
34.68 |
22 |
34.22 |
55 |
28.22 |
55 |
|||
MPT/t |
38.00 |
22 |
.024 |
37.00 |
55 |
.001 |
31.29 |
55 |
.001 |
MPR/i |
43.18 |
22 |
41.24 |
55 |
38.20 |
55 |
|||
MPR/t |
44.46 |
22 |
.534 |
43.09 |
55 |
.113 |
42.07 |
55 |
.001 |
MIV/i |
29.27 |
22 |
28.11 |
55 |
10.09 |
55 |
|||
MIV/t |
36.46 |
22 |
.084 |
30.76 |
55 |
.075 |
10.56 |
55 |
.709 |
F6'/i |
1086.96 |
22 |
1168.64 |
55 |
921.93 |
55 |
|||
F6'/t |
1210.46 |
22 |
.003 |
1214.31 |
55 |
.039 |
974.15 |
55 |
.007 |
Note: Var. – variable / Per. – measurement period (i – initial, t – transitive, f – final); Mean – arithmetic mean; N – number of entities in the sample; p – level of significance; the leading zeros have been left out.
of a person's nutritional status (ITM) and flexibility of the pelvis (MPR).
Table 3 shows the examinees non-athletes' results between the second and third measurement. A positive move was recorded in all variables, the results being statistically significant in nine variables (ATV, ATT, AOP, MTR, MSD, MPN, MPT, MIV and F6').
The correlation analysis results of the total sample of examinees (Table 7) show that there is a statistically significant correlation (error level p = .01) between the body mass index (ITM) and the functional abilities measured with the six minute run test (F6'). The correlation coefficient was negative for all three evaluations and it was equal to r = –.422 for the initial measurement, r = –.480 for the transitive measurement and r = –.397 at the final measurement.
The average values of the examinees' nutritional state (Fig. 1) clearly show the difference between the group of non-athletes and athletes. Non-athletes recorded 20 and more centiles higher values at the final measurement than the two groups of athletes. If the final measurement results are seen according to the nutritional state, it can be seen that 55 % of non-athletes are overweight or obese. Of the total number of overweight or obese non-athletes, 90.32 % kept the measured values during the two-year period of assessment. The team sports played with a ball and martial arts examinees are predominantly of a normal body mass.
The obtained results indicate that young athletes engaged in martial arts (wrestling, karate, kick-boxing and taekwondo) achieved significant positive moves of the anthropological status after a two-year priod of organised training processes.
In the first part of the analysed period, during the fifth grade, the anthropometric characteristics results for boys engaged in martial arts indicate a statistically significant positive increase in the body height (ATV), body mass (ATT) and forearm girth (AOP). The examinees achieved an average growth of 6.7 cm, they were 3.5 kg heavier and their forearm girth was about 1 cm longer. Regarding their age, the obtained results, especially in regard to body height and body mass, are slightly above the average when compared to results found in earlier literature [13].
Table 3
Martial arts |
Sports played with a ball |
Non-athletes |
|||||||
Var./Per. |
Mean |
N |
p < .05 |
Mean |
N |
p < .05 |
Mean |
N |
p < .05 |
ATV/t |
155.57 |
27 |
157.65 |
57 |
155.76 |
52 |
|||
ATV/f |
163.64 |
27 |
.000 |
165.16 |
57 |
.000 |
162.27 |
52 |
.000 |
ATT/t |
46.94 |
27 |
46.87 |
57 |
56.06 |
52 |
|||
ATT/f |
53.47 |
27 |
.000 |
53.32 |
57 |
.000 |
62.90 |
52 |
.000 |
AOP/t |
22.56 |
25 |
22.63 |
57 |
23.96 |
52 |
|||
AOP/f |
23.47 |
25 |
.001 |
23.55 |
57 |
.000 |
24.88 |
52 |
.000 |
ITM/t |
50.52 |
27 |
53.53 |
57 |
76.06 |
52 |
|||
ITM/f |
51.33 |
27 |
.743 |
53.30 |
57 |
.894 |
76.00 |
52 |
.969 |
MTR/t |
27.04 |
28 |
26.75 |
59 |
25.84 |
57 |
|||
MTR/f |
27.96 |
28 |
.252 |
29.03 |
59 |
.000 |
27.42 |
57 |
.000 |
MSD/t |
166.54 |
28 |
161.00 |
59 |
140.14 |
57 |
|||
MSD/f |
174.04 |
28 |
.001 |
174.92 |
59 |
.000 |
149.88 |
57 |
.000 |
MPN/t |
14.08 |
27 |
14.59 |
59 |
19.43 |
57 |
|||
MPN/f |
11.95 |
27 |
.000 |
12.99 |
59 |
.000 |
17.52 |
57 |
.000 |
MPT/t |
37.86 |
28 |
37.41 |
59 |
31.47 |
57 |
|||
MPT/f |
40.60 |
28 |
.066 |
40.88 |
59 |
.000 |
34.75 |
57 |
.000 |
MPR/t |
45.39 |
28 |
44.05 |
59 |
42.54 |
57 |
|||
MPR/f |
49.46 |
28 |
.025 |
45.97 |
59 |
.142 |
43.75 |
57 |
.265 |
MIV/t |
33.12 |
28 |
29.63 |
59 |
10.35 |
57 |
|||
MIV/f |
38.64 |
28 |
.039 |
37.25 |
59 |
.000 |
14.61 |
57 |
.008 |
F6'/t |
1164.82 |
28 |
1204.53 |
59 |
968.30 |
57 |
|||
F6'/f |
1272.71 |
28 |
.002 |
1262.56 |
59 |
.008 |
1012.67 |
57 |
.016 |
T-test results for dependable samples between the transitive and final measurements of examinees engaging in martial arts, team sports played with a ball and non-athletes
Note: Var. – variable / Per. – measurement period (i – initial, t – transitive, f – final); Mean – arithmetic mean; N – number of entities in the sample; p – level of significance; the leading zeros have been left out.
The discriminant analysis results at the initial measurement
Table 4
Eigenvalues |
Canonical correlation |
Wilks' Lambda |
Chisquare |
p < .05 |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
|
Differences in results between martial art groups and non-athletes |
.75 |
.66 |
.57 |
35.06 |
.000 |
1.31 |
–.56 |
Differences in results between groups playing team sports with a ball and non-athletes |
.91 |
.69 |
.52 |
60.46 |
.000 |
.92 |
–.97 |
Differences in results between martial art groups and groups playing team sports with a ball |
.26 |
.45 |
.80 |
14.95 |
.185 |
.79 |
–.32 |
Note: here and in Table. 5, 6 Eigenvalues – discriminant functions' characteristical values; Canonical Correlation – canonical correlation coefficients; Wilk's Lambda – Wilk's Lambda values for each discriminant function; Chi-Sqr. – the value of the hi square test for the assessment of the discriminant function significance; p-level – the proportion of the error done by accepting the hypothesis that the difference is statistically significant: Group 1 – the position of the first group centroids on the discrimnant function; Group 2 – the position of the second group centroids on the discrimnant function; the leading zeros have been left out.
Table 5
The discriminant analysis results at the transitive measurement
Eigenvalues |
Canonical correlation |
Wilks' Lambda |
Chisquare |
p < .05 |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
|
Differences in results between martial art groups and non-athletes |
.60 |
.61 |
.63 |
34.09 |
.000 |
1.04 |
–.56 |
Differences in results between groups playing team sports with a ball and non-athletes |
.81 |
.67 |
.55 |
60.84 |
.000 |
.85 |
–.94 |
Differences in results between martial art groups and groups playing team sports with a ball |
.20 |
.41 |
.84 |
14.17 |
.224 |
.63 |
–.31 |
Table 6
The discriminant analysis results at the final measurement
Eigenvalues |
Canonical correlation |
Wilks' Lambda |
Chisquare |
p < .05 |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
|
Differences in results between martial art groups and non-athletes |
.64 |
.63 |
.61 |
36.51 |
.000 |
1.19 |
–.53 |
Differences in results between groups playing team sports with a ball and non-athletes |
.69 |
.64 |
.59 |
56.31 |
.000 |
.80 |
–.84 |
Differences in results between martial art groups and groups playing team sports with a ball |
.13 |
.34 |
.89 |
9.24 |
.600 |
–.54 |
.23 |
At the end of the first year of the training process, the martial arts examinees did not show a signify-cant advancement in the variables which measure flexibility (MPR), the explosive power of the legs (MSD) and the static power of the arms and shoulders (MIV). However, these three motor abilities results showed a statistically significant improvement after the second year of training and so confirmed some earlier researches' results [21, 45]. The reason for the improvement of flexibility can probably be found in better trained techniques like high kicks in karate, taekwondo, kick-boxing and a number of specific gripping, lifting, throwing and turning techniques in the stand-up and floor position in wrestling which contribute to a better flexibility of the hips, the whole pelvis area, the lower trunk and the back region of lower limbs. „A high level of these abilities makes possible movements which are more economical, fatigue is easier to endure, the sensitivity to the occurrence of acute and chronic injuries is lower, psycho-physical relaxation etc.“ [47]. Flexibility is the only motor ability which produces the best results and values in childhood, which is significant for all martial arts [45]. At the end of the observed training period for all measured types of action, power re- sponse (explosive, repetitive and static) and expressed advancement was seen, especially in the explosive and static power where statistically significant improvements are recorded. They are certainly conditioned by a number of different factors, from the chronological to the significantly biological age, and also by factors linked to the sole training – volume, intensity and duration of the training [31]. The results achieved by boys engaged in martial arts are incouraging, since too little attention was paid to the strength and flexibility of the trunk [2]. “Insufficient attention paid to the strength and flexibility of the trunk in the basic preparation stage (from 10 to 14 years of age) will be reflected as a lag in learning the advanced techniques of lifting from the floor at the stage of direct specializing preparation (from 15 to 18 years of age) which will eventually cause sport stagnation and a permanent latent danger of injuries to the trunk“ [3]. The variable which continually records a significant positive move in the two-year period is the variable for the measurement of functional abilities – the six minute run (F6'). Although power, speed of motoric reaction, coordination… [23, 24, 26, 43] are predominant for the success in martial arts, which more precisely represent the
Table 7
The correlation between the body mass index variable and the test for measuring functional abilities (F6')
F6' Initial |
F6' Transitive |
F6' Final |
|
ITM Martial arts |
–.032 |
–.462 |
–.292 |
ITM Team sports played with a ball |
–.340 |
–.338 |
–.086 |
ITM Non-athletes |
–.313 |
–.334 |
–.409 |
ITM Total |
–.422 |
–.480 |
–.397 |
Note: Level of error p < .01; the leadin g zeros have been left out.
dominance of speed-strength abilities, the permanent advancement and total achievement in the aerobic capacity of martial arts athletes is seen as an envious success. Functional abilities of an aerobic character are essential for an adequate recovery between rounds or matches at competitions, but also for the recovery during and after a training [25, 44]. It is known that a well developed aerobic capacity at this age is the base for working on the sport-specific anaerobic endurance in the ages to come. According to Bompa [6], the children's organs and systems adaptation to the endurance training has many good sides, from improving the lung and heart functions to the increase of red blood cells in charge of the transfer of oxygen to the muscles engaged.
ITVI - final testing accordingto groups

Fig. 1. Average values of the body mass index (ITM) at the final measurement for all three groups of examinees: 1 – sports played with a ball; 2 – martial arts; 3 – non-athletes
ball, athletes in sport games played with a ball have an advantage over their peers from the two other groups already in the initial phase of puberty. In the area of functional-motor abilities, positive moves in all the measured variables were achieved after one year of training. The variables which measure the explosive and static power (MSD and MIV) and the flexibility of the pelvis (MPR) were the only ones which did not show a statistical advancement. The variable touch-toe with legs astride (MPR) did not register significant changes even after the second year of the training process which indicates that exercises which develop flexibility are not sufficiently present in the sport games played with a ball training contents. There are more than one earlier researches which show that flexibility does not sig-nificatly change in team sports [35]. Although boys' flexibility diminishes after their eleventh year of age, action should be taken to improve it [25]. The flexibility of the back thigh muscles has a keyrole for the execution of a number of specific tasks in football, like young football players' sprinting, jumping, agility and kicks [15]. Its importance is significant for the execution of certain basketball technique elements [26]. The same authors emphasize that an adequate flexibility is a support to a quality growth and development, as well as to the prevention of injuries. The results obtained in the area of explosive and static power after a one-year training period do not confirm some earlier researches [18, 32]. The reasons can be only assumed. On one hand, the popularity of sports played with a ball attracts a larger number of children (than martial arts) which dimin-shes the coach's individual approach to each single person, while on the other, there is a larger number of children who, due to a lack of interest, train without the wish and will to succeed which after a time leads to giving up training these sports. It is certain that persistent and motivated boys who find it harder to reach their condition potentials directly suffer from such circumstances. The end of the two-year period brought significant positive moves for these two measured variables of motor abilities. Like the martial arts examinees, a statistically significant improvement in the functional ability variable (F6') was registered for young team sports athletes after the first and second year of the training process. If the average value results for the two groups at the initial, transitive and final measurements are taken into consideration, it can be concluded that young athletes playing sport games with a ball have better results at the initial (M = +81 m) and transitive (M = +40 m) measurement, while the results are worse at the final measurement (M = -10 m). According to Mikulic [27], “a significant improvement in the aerobic endurance indicators, it has been determined, is achieved from the beginning of the intensive puberty growth in height, which is averagely one year after a boy enters puberty or around their 13th year of age.” Since the functional ability (F6’) is a precondition for the qualitative and quantitative engagement in team sports played with a ball, a higher improvement was expected in the second year of the training process. In giving the periodization of children’s long term trainings, Bompa [6] names the puberty period as the formation of athletes phase (11 to 14 years of age) when the aerobic capacity should be further developed. He adds that a strong endurance base will enable athletes to face the training and competition requirements in a more efficient way during the following phase (15 to 18 years of age) which is called specialization.
Like the two groups of young athletes engaged in martial arts and team sports played with a ball, pupils who are physically active in an organised way only during Physical Education classes achieve a statistically significant improvement during the two-year measurement period in almost all variables linked to anthropometric characteristics and functional-motor abilities. Only the variable for measuring the flexibility of the pelvis (MPR), which registered a significant improvement in the first year, did not show a significant positive move at the last measurement. Flexibility often declines with years, especially for boys, probably due to the muscle growth, growth and muscle strength so it demands training during the young’s developmental phases [6]. This research results show that an adequate Physical Education curriculum, primarily based on feedback information of the pupils actual condition and by considering their interests and needs, would reach a certain positive move of kinanthropological tasks. Unlike in previous researches [37], the obtained results indicate the contrary effects of the Physcal Education transformative process. More significant cummulative effects of the children's whole anthropological status are only possible if higher values of the load's extensity and intensity are applied. This is the reason why the non-athletes' results, when considering all the measured variables, are significantly behind the results achieved by peer athletes engaged in martial arts and team sports played with a ball. They are especially manifested on the anthropometrical characteristics' values in the variables body mass and forearm girth (ATT, AOP), similarly to results obtained by certain previous researches [44]. It confirms the further negative trend of increment in the children and adolescents' body mass which was mentioned at the beginning of this article. Unlike the two groups of athletes whose results were permanently similar, pupils non-athletes had a higher body mass (averagely from 7 to 9 kg) and larger forearm girth (averagely 1.5 cm) from the initial to the final measurement. Although the forearm crease was not measured, when the lower values of the pupils non-athletes body height and their sedentary way of life are considered, it can be easily concluded that Physical Education classes held twice a week for 45 minutes only slightly diminishes the growth of the ballast mass, but it does not reduce it to a significant extent.
It should be pointed out that examinees in this research lived in rural and suburban areas and attended school in two shifts. A larger number of pupils was not able to come to trainings in the city on foot, nor could parents drive them due to their job obligations. Since an increase in the number of primary school Physical Education classes from twice to three times a week cannot be anticipated in due time, it is essential for the school and the social environment to encourage the pupils' participation in extracurricular activities, school sport associations and sport clubs. By taking part in some of the aforementioned forms of organised physical exercising, they would accumulate the necessary time to be spent in an organised physical activity and surely give a contribution to the positive improvement of their kinanthropological status.
The correlation analysis results of the total sample of examinees regarding the body mass index (ITM) and functional abilities leads to the conclusion that an increase in the value of the body mass index is influenced by the poorer result achieved at the six minute run test (F6'). Overweight or obese examinees in all three groups showed a significantly poorer result at the final measurement in comparison to the normally nou- rished or malnourished. Namely, their six minute running section was averagely 156 m shorter than all the examinees total result and 216 m shorter than the result of examinees in the cathegory of normal body mass or malnourishment. The results obtained in this research give an additional confirmation to the current knowledge which says that a poorer execution of functional ability tests is closely related to the presence of excess weight and obesity. Previous studies conducted in our country and in the world show that children and adolescents with a higher body mass achieve poorer results in the area of functionalmotor abilities than their normal body mass peers [7, 19, 34, 38, 40, 42]. By consulting twelve transversal and two longitudinal studies published in relevant electronic academic data bases (PubMed, SportDiscus, Web of knowledge and Ovid) in the period from 2000 to 2011, the authors Rauner et al. [41] analysed the interaction of physical activity, physical fitness (muscle strength, endurance and motor skills) and excess body mass in adolescents and the young aged 11 to 23. The conclusion of a larger number of studies about the relation between excess body mass including obesity and physical activity lies in their reversed correlation. All the twelve transversal studies report about the reverse correlation between physical fitness and body mass. In line with the results, this paper can confirm the set hypothesis according to which there is a statistically significant correlation between the body mass index (ITM) and the functional abilities for the three groups of examinees.
Conclusion
The discriminant analysis results showed the superiority of both groups of athletes over the pupils non-athletes at the initial, final and transitive measurement. During the two-year training period the two groups of athletes did not show significant differences. Based on the obtained results, it can be concluded that engaging in team sports played with a ball at the secondary school age (11 to 13) has a more positive and significant influence on the development of the analysed anthropometrical characteristics, motor and functional abilities' variables than on those peer pupils who did not engage in sports, but not on athletes engaged in martial arts. Thus, the set alternative hypothesis is partially accepted. More precisely, the alternative hypothesis according to which there is a statistically significant difference in the changes of the anthropological status for children athletes engaged in team sports played with a ball in comparison to children who are non-athletes is accepted, while the alternative hypothesis is rejected because a statistically significant difference in the changes of the anthropological status between the groups of team sports played with a ball and martial arts was not determined so the null hypothesis is accepted.
Pupils who were engaged in organised exercising only during Physical Education classes twice a week for 45 minutes, although they achieved a significant improvement (t-test for dependable samples) in almost all variables of the anthropological status during the two-year activities, could not cope with peers who trained team sports played with a ball or martial arts as part of their extracurricular activities – three times a week for at least 60 minutes. This article's results also indicte that Physical Education classes are not sufficient for a long term significant influence on the children and adolescents' kinathropological characteristics. It is essential for the local community to ensure the possibility for children to attend school only in the morning shift, while the school and the community as a whole should be more engaged into offering the interested pupils the possibility to take part into organised forms of sports and make them simple and more available.
Since this article did not analyse the content aspects of the two groups of athletes' training and the represetation of examinees according to sports varied significantly, the results should be taken with a pinch of salt. Future studies should equalize the number of examinees according to particular sports, increase the total number of examinees per groups and consider a larger number of factors, primarily egsogenous, like information about the training process of the chosen sports, attendance of trainings, pupils nutritional habits, free time activities and others. In any case, it was expected that the differences between the two groups of athletes compared to the group of non-athletes would increase over time, but it did not happen. Some of the reasons can be found in insufficiently experienced coaches and a lower level of professionalism which raises a question about the necessary quality of the training work, training conditions and the children's interest for a certain sport activity. The basic precondition for an adequate progress and development of the children's conditional potential for the chosen sport is a professional and experienced coach who knows the working and developmental regulations and applies contemporary knowledge about planning and programming the training process in his/her work. Such a coaching profile would contribute to keeping children and adolescents engaged in the chosen sport and it would indirectly cause physical exercising to become children's permanent possession.
Список литературы Quantitative changes in the anthropological status of middle school aged pupils over a two-year period
- Badrić M., Sporiš G., Krstičević T. Razlikeu Motoričkim Sposobnostima Učenika Prema Razini Tjelesne Aktivnostiu Slobodno Vrijeme//Hrvatski Športskomedicinski Vjesnik, 2015, no. 30, pp. 92-98.
- Baić M. Razlikeu Razini Izabranih Motoričkihi Funkcionalnih Sposobnosti Kod Poljskihi Hrvatskih Hrvača Klasičnim Načinom (Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Kinesiology, University of Zagreb). Zagrebu, Kineziološki Fakultet Sveučilištau Zagrebu, 2003.
- Baić M., Marić J., Valentić M. Bazične i Specifične Hrvačke Vježbe u Parovima za Razvoj Snage i Fleksibilnosti Trupa//Kondicijski Trening, 2004, no. 2 (2), pp. 34-43.
- Baron R.A., Byrne D. Social Psychology. Boston, Allyn end Bacon, 2000.
- Biro F.M., Wien M. Childhood Obesity and Adult Morbidities//American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2010, no. 91 (5), pp. 1499-1505.
- Bompa T. Cjelokupan Trening za Mlade Pobjednike. Zagreb//Hrvatski Košarkaški Savez & Udruga Hrvatskih Košarkaških Trenera, 2000.
- Casonatto J., Araujo Fernandes R., Biagi Batista M., Serpeloni Cyrino E., Coelho-e-Silva M.J., de Arruda M., Vaz Ronque E.R. Association Between Health-Related Physical Fitness and Body Mass Index Status in Children//Journal of Child Health Care, 2016, no. 20 (3), pp. 294-303.
- Chen L.J., Fox K.R., Haase A., Wang J.M. Obesity, Fitness and Health in Taiwanese Children and Adolescents//European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2006, no. 60 (12), pp. 1367-1375.
- Cole T.J., Bellizzi M.C., Flegal K.M., Dietz W.H. Establishing a Standard Definition for Child Overweight and Obesity Worldwide: International Survey//British Medical Journal, 2000, no. 320, pp. 1240-1243 DOI: 10.1136/bmj.320.7244.1240
- Davis L., Jowett S. Attachment Styles within the Coach-Athlete Dyad: Preliminary Investigation and Assessment Development//Journal of Clinical Sport Psychology, 2013, no. 7 (2), pp. 120-145.
- De Onis M., Onyango A.W., Borghi E., Siyam A., Nishida C., Siekmann J. Development of a WHO Growth Reference for School-Aged Children and Adolescents//Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2007, no. 85 (9), pp. 660-667.
- Findak V., Metikoš D., Mraković M., Neljak B. Primijenjena Kineziologija u Školstvu -Norme. Zagreb//Hrvatski Pedagoško-Književni Zbor., 1996.
- Findak V. Metodika Tjelesne i Zdravstvene Kulture: Priručnik za Nastavnike Tjelesne i Zdravstvene Culture. Zagreb, Školska Knjiga, 2001.
- Fransen J., Pion J., Vandendriessche J., Vandorpe B., Vaeyens R., Lenoir M., Philippaerts R.M. Differences in Physical Fitness and Gross Motor Coordination in Boys Aged 6-12 Years Specializing in One Versus Sampling More than One Sport//Journal of Sports Sciences, 2012, no. 30 (4), pp. 379-386.
- García-Pinillos F., Ruiz-Ariza A., Moreno del Castillo R., Latorre-Román P.A. Impact of Limited Hamstring Flexibility on Vertical Jump, Kicking Speed, Sprint, and Agility in Young Football Players//Journal of Sports Sciences, 2015, no. 33 (12), pp. 1293-1297.
- Inchley J. et al. Growing up Unequal: Gender and Socioeconomic Differences in Young Peopleʹs Health and Well-Being. Health Behavior in School-Age Children (HBSC) Study: International Report From 2013/2014 Survey. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2016.
- Jinzhou Y., Fu Y., Zhang R., Li X., Shan G. The Reliability and Sensitivity of Indices Related to Cardiovascular Fitness Evaluation//Kinesiology, 2008, no. 40 (2), pp. 138-145.
- Jovanović M., Tadić M., Krakan I., Findak V. Utjecaj Organiziranog Rekreacijskog Bavljenja Nogometom na Eksplozivnu Snagu, Repetitivnu Snagu i Fleksibilnost Školske Djece od 11. do 12. Godine. Zbornik Radova 20//Ljetne Škole Kineziologa Republike Hrvatske, Poreč. 2011, pp. 196-201.
- Jureša V., Musil V., Majer M., Heimer S. Stanje Pretilosti Djece u Hrvatskoj. Tjelesna Aktivnost i Zdravlje -Uloga Tjelesne Aktivnosti u Prevenciji i Liječenju Prekomjerne Težine i Pretilosti, Zagreb, 2011, pp. 16-18.
- Kopelman P. Health Risks Associated with Overweight and Obesity//Obesity Reviews, 2007, no. 8 (1), pp. 13-17.
- Krstulović S., Maleš B., Žuvela F., Erceg M., Miletić Đ. Judo, Soccer and Track-and-Field Differential Effects on Some Anthropological Characteristics in Seven-Year-Old Boys//Kinesiology, 2010, no. 42 (1), pp. 56-64.
- Luciano A., Piccoli A., Bonetti P., Romano R., Bolognani M., Castellarin A., Zoppi G. BMI Centile as an Indicator of Degree of Obesity in Childhood//La Pediatria Medica e Chirurgica: Medical and Surgical Paediatrics, 2001, no. 23 (3-4), pp. 183-185.
- Marić J., Baić M., Aračić M., Milanović D., Jukić I. Kondicijska Priprema Hrvača//Zbornik Radova Međunarodnog Znanstveno-Stručnog Skupa Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša, Zagreb, 2003, pp. 339-346.
- Marković G.,Milanović D., Jukić I. Teorijske i Metodičke Osnove Kondicijske Pripreme u Taekwondou//Zbornik Radova Međunarodnog Znanstveno-Stručnog Skupa Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša, Zagreb, 2003, pp. 549-556.
- Marković G., Badrić A. Nogomet -Integralni Kondicijski Trening. Zagreb. Udruga „Tjelesno Vježbanje i Zdravlje", 2008.
- Matković B., Knjaz D., Ćosić B., Milanović D., Jukić I. Smjernice Fizičke Pripreme u Košarci//Zbornik Radova Međunarodnog Znanstveno-Stručnog Skupa Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša, Zagreb, 2003, pp. 390-394.
- Mikulić P., Jukić, I., Milanović, D., Gregov C., Šalaj S. Metodika Treninga Izdržljivosti Djece i Mladih Sportaša -Osvrt na Biološku i Kronološku Dob//Zbornik Radova 7. Godišnja Međunarodna Konferencija Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša -Trening Izdržljivosti, Zagreb, 2009, pp. 36-38.
- Milanović D. Teorija Treninga -Kineziologija Sporta. Zagreb: Kineziološki fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu, 2013.
- Mišigoj-Duraković M., Matković B., Jukić I., Milanović D., Šimek S. Biološke i Funkcionalne Osobitosti Dječje i Adolescentne Dobi i Sportski Trening//Zbornik Radova 5. Godišnja Međunarodna Konferencija Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša -Kondicijska Priprema Djece i Mladih, Zagreb, 2007, pp. 39-45.
- Mišigoj-Duraković M. Kinantropologija, Biološki Aspekti Tjelesnog Vježbanja. Kineziološki Fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu, 2008.
- Mišigoj-Duraković M., Sorić M., Duraković Z., Heimer S. Zdravstvene Koristi Tjelesne Aktivnosti i Vježbanja Kod Djece i Adolescenata//Tjelesna Aktivnost i Zdravlje -Uloga Tjelesne Aktivnosti u Prevenciji i Liječenju Prekomjerne Težine i Pretilosti, Zagreb, 2011, pp. 19-23.
- Muratović A., Petković J., Bojanić D., Vasiljević I. Comparative Analysis of Motor and Specific Motor Abilities Between Handball Players and Non-Athletes in the Cadet Age From Montenegro//Acta Kinesiologica, 2015, no. 9 (1), pp. 70-74.
- Neljak B., Milanović D., Jukić, I., Milanović D., Šimek S. Organizacijski, Programski i Materijalni Uvjeti za Redovito Tjelesno Vježbanje Djece i Mladeži//Zbornik Radova 5. Godišnja Međunarodna Konferencija Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša -Kondicijska Priprema Djece i Mladih, Zagreb, 2007, pp. 32-38.
- Nikolaidis P.T., Ingebrigtsen J. The Relationship Between Body Mass Index and Physical Fitness in Adolescent and Adult Male Team Handball Players//Indian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology, 2015, no. 57 (4), pp. 361-371.
- Oliveira A., Monteiro Â., Jácome C., Afreixo V., Marques A. Effects of Group Sports on Health-Related Physical Fitness of Overweight Youth: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis//Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports.2016, no. 7.
- Ortega F.B., Ruiz J.R., Castillo M.J., Sjöström M. Physical Fitness in Childhood and Adolescence: a Powerful Marker of Health//International Journal of Obesity, 2008, no. 32, pp. 3-11 DOI: 10.1038/sj.ijo.0803774
- Partavi S. Effects of 7 Weeks of Rope-Jump Training on Cardiovascular Endurance, Speed and Agility in Middle School Student Boys//Sport Science, 2013, no. 6 (2), pp. 40-43.
- Petrić V., Neljak B.Povezanost Indeksa Tjelesne Mase i Funkcionalnih Sposobnosti te Razlike u Istima Između Učenika Urbanih Naselja i Ruralnih Sredina//Zbornik Radova 18. Ljetne Škole Kineziologa Republike Hrvatske, Poreč. 2009, pp. 214-220.
- Podnar H., Čule M., Šafarić Z., Findak V. Dijagnostika Stanja Uhranjenosti Učenika Osnovnih Škola Grada Zagreba//Zbornik Radova 22. Ljetne Škole Kineziologa Republike Hrvatske, Poreč, 2013, pp. 522-527.
- Prskalo I., Badrić M., Kunješić M. The Percentage of Body Fat in Children and the Level of their Motor Skills//Collegium Antropologicum, 2015, no. 39 (1), pp. 21-28.
- Rauner A., Mess F., Woll A. The Relationship Between Physical Activity, Physical Fitness and Overweight in Adolescents: a Systematic Review of Studies Published in or After 2000//BMC Pediatrics, 2013, pp. 13-19 DOI: 10.1201/b16340-7
- Sekulić D., Metikoš D., Sveučilište S. Osnove Transformacijskih Postupaka u Kineziologiji. Fakultet Prirodoslovno-Matematičkih Znanosti i Kineziologije, 2007.
- Sertić H. Osnove Borilačkih Sportova. Zagreb. Kineziološki Fakultet Sveučilišta u Zagrebu, 2004.
- Sertić H., Segedi I., Vidranski T., Jukić I., Milanović D., Gregov C., Šalaj S. Je li Izdržljivost Ključna za Bolji Rezultat u Judu, Karateu i Tae Kwon Dou?//Zbornik Radova 7. Godišnja Međunarodna Konferencija Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša -Trening Izdržljivosti, Zagreb, 2009, pp. 411-414.
- Sertić H., Segedi I., Prskalo I. Dinamika Razvoja Antropoloških Obilježja Tijekom Dvogodišnjeg Perioda Kod Kesportaša, Dječaka Koji se Bave Momčadskim Sportovima i Judaša//Napredak, 2010, no. 151 (3-4), pp. 466-481.
- Stratton G., Canoy D., Boddy L.M., Taylor S.R., Hackett A.F., Buchan I.E. Cardiorespiratory Fitness and Body Mass Index of 9-11-Year-Old English Children: A Serial Cross-Sectional Study from 1998 to 2004//International Journal of Obesity, 2007, no. 31 (7), pp. 1172-1178.
- Šarabon N., Jukić I., Milanović D., Šimek S. Priprema Mladog Lokomotornog Aparata za Siguran i Učinkovit Prijelaz u Seniorski Natjecateljski Sport//Zbornik Radova 5. Gdišnja Međunarodna Konferencija Kondicijska Priprema Sportaša -Kondicijska Priprema Djece i Madih, Zagreb, 2007, pp. 56-62.
- Tomkinson G.R., Léger L.A., Olds T.S., Cazorla G. Secular Trends in the Performance of Children and Adolescents (1980-2000): an Analysis of 55 Studies of the 20 m Shuttle Run Test in 11 Countries//Sports Medicine, 2003, no. 33 (4), pp. 285-300.
- Trninić V., Papić V., Trninić M. Role of Expert Coaches in Development of Top-Level Athletes' Careers in Individual and Team Sports//Acta Kinesiologica, 2009, no. 3 (1), pp. 99-106.
- World Health Organization Global Recommendations on Physical Activity for Health, 2010.