Artificial vs human intelligence in the educational process of university

In the context of total digitalization of education, problems connected with the implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies, as well as issues related to the role of a person as a carrier of human intelligence (HI) in the educational process, become especially topical for universities. The increasing penetration of AI into many areas of higher education requires a balanced approach, considering all the pros and cons, assessing the risks and consequences for humans as subjects of education. The goal of the article is to compare AI and HI capabilities in the educational process of a university. The authors set and solved the following tasks: 1) to study the theoretical material and practical experience of Russian universities in the aspect of applying AI and HI in higher education; 2) to study the concepts of “artificial intelligence” and “human intelligence”; 3) to identify the advantages and disadvantages of AI and HI for the educational process at a university; 4) to present the comparative description of AI and HI in the educational process of a university; 5) to define the perspectives for the development of AI and HI in higher education. To solve the tasks the methods of analysis of scientific literature, analysis of regulatory documents, study and generalization of advanced pedagogical experience, and comparative analysis are used. The results indicate that the issues of introducing AI technologies into the educational process of universities are topical for the state and society. In theory, there is no consensus on the definition of the AI phenomenon, while HI is interpreted as the sum of a person's cognitive abilities. The review of practice shows a wide range of applicability of AI technologies in universities: from automating routine tasks to creating an immersive educational environment. The comparative analysis of the capabilities of AI and HI has been carried out according to the following parameters: processing and analysis of big data, adaptive learning, interactivity, feedback, creative thinking and critical thinking, complexity of tasks, ethics and morality, emotional communication, objectivity of assessment. The analysis shows that AI and HI in relation to higher education have advantages and disadvantages. A promising scenario for the future development of the system of higher education under the influence of AI technologies will be the integration of AI and HI, which opens up new opportunities for humans in Education 4.0.