Состояние власти позднеимперской России в оценке англо-американской историографии 2-й половины XX - начала XXI в

Автор: Любичанковский С.В.

Журнал: Известия Самарского научного центра Российской академии наук @izvestiya-ssc

Статья в выпуске: 2 т.9, 2007 года.

Бесплатный доступ

В статье анализируется англо-американская историография 2-й половины XX - начала XXI в., посвящен- ная проблеме состояния власти позднеимперской России. Устанавливаются и систематизируются основ- ные характеристики российской бюрократии и государственного аппарата, предложенные в зарубежной научной литературе. Делается вывод о том, что англо-американские работы по истории отечественной до- революционной бюрократии представляют собой методологически единое научное направление. Сопос- тавляются подходы зарубежных и отечественных авторов по исследуемой проблеме.

Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/148197943

IDR: 148197943

Список литературы Состояние власти позднеимперской России в оценке англо-американской историографии 2-й половины XX - начала XXI в

Любичанковский С.В. Основные подходы к изучению кризиса власти позднеимперской России в отечественной исторической науке//Самарский земский сборник. -2006. -№1 -2. -С.238 -245.
Thatcher I.D. Introduction//Late imperial Russia. Problems and prospects. Ed. by I.D. Thatcher. -Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press, 2005. -208p. -P.1.
McKean R.B. Russia on the Eve of the Great War: Revolution or Revolution? -PhD Thesis: University of East Anglia, 1971. -P.290 -334
McKean R.B. St Petersburg Between the revolutions: Workers and revolutionaries, June 1907 -February 1917. -London: 1990.
Haimson L.H. The Problem of Social Stability in Urban Russia. 1905 -1917//Slavic review. 1964. Vol.23. №4. -P.619-642 Ibid. 1965. Vol.24. №1. P.1 -22
Хеймсон Л. Проблема социальной стабильности в городской России 1905-1917 гг.//Нестор. -2004. -№3. -СПб.: 2004. -С.135 -161
Хеймсон Л. Об истоках революции//Отечественная история. -1993. -№6. -С.3 -15;
Haimson L.H. The Problem of Political and Social Stability in Urban Russia on the Eve of War and Revolution Revisited//Slavic review. 2000. Vol.59. №4. P.848-875
Хеймсон Л. Проблема политической и социальной стабильности в городской России накануне войны и революции: современный взгляд//Нестор. -2004. -№3. -СПб.: 2004. -С.169 -192
Read C. In Search of Liberal Tsarism: The Historiography of Autocratic Decline//Historical Journal. -2000. -№45 (1). -P.195 -210.
Modernization and Revolutions. Dilemmas of Progress in Late Imperial Russia. Ed. by E.H. Judge, J.Y. Simms, jr. -New York: Columbia University Press, 1992. -206p. -P.10 -11.
McKean R.B. St Petersburg Between the revolutions: Workers and revolutionaries, June 1907 -February 1917. -London: 1990
McKean R.B. Between the Revolutions: Russia 1905 to 1917. -London: 1998.
Orlovsky D.T. Recent studies on the Russian bureaucracy//Russian Review. 1976, oct. Vol.35. №4. -P.448 -467.
Rowney D.K., Pintner W.M. Officialdom and bureaucratization: an introduction//Russian officialdom. The bureaucratization of Russian Society from the 17 to the 20 century. Ed. by W. McKenzie Pinther and L.K. Rowney. -Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina press, 1980. -396p. -P.3 -18. -P.5.
Величенко С. Численность бюрократии и армии в Российской империи в сравнительной перспективе//Российская империя в зарубежной историографии. Работы последних лет: Антология/Сост. П.Верт, П.С.Кабытов, А.И.Миллер. -М.: Новое изд-во, 2005. -С.83 -115
Yaney G.L. The Systematization of Russion Government. Social Evolution in the Administration of Imperial Russia, 1711 -1905. -Urbana: Chicago, London: University of Illinois, 1973. -430p. -P.334 -335
Pearson T.S. Russian Officialdom in Crisis. Autocracy and Local Self-Government, 1861 -1900. -Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989. -284p. -P.257
Weissman N.B. Reform in Tsarist Russia. The State Bureaucracy and Local Government, 1900 -1914. -Rutgers University Press. New Brunswick, New Jersey. 1981. -292p. -P.225
Robbins R.G., jr. The Tsar's Viceroys. Russian Provincial Governors in the Last Years of the Empire. -Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 1987. -271p. -P.19, 183;
Badcock S. Autocracy in crisis: Nicholas the last//Late imperial Russia. Problems and prospects. Ed. by I.D. Thatcher. -Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press, 2005. -208p. -P.9 -27. -P.24 -25.
Pintner W.M., Rowney D.K. Officialdom and bureaucratization: conclusion//Russian officialdom. The bureaucratization of Russian Society from the 17 to the 20 century. Ed. by W. McKenzie Pinther and L.K. Rowney. -Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina press, 1980. -396p. -P.369 -380. -P.371;
Raeff M. The Bureaucratic Phenomena of Imperial Russia, 1700 -1905//The American Historical Review. April 1979. Vol.84. №2. -P.399 -411. -P.408
Sternheimer S. Administering Development and Developing Administration: Organizational Conflict on Tsarist Bureaucracy, 1906 -1914//Canadian-American Slavic Studies. A quarterly journal devoted to Russia and East Europe. 1975. Vol.9. №3. -P.277 -301. -P.291.
Robbins R.G., jr. Choosing the Russian Governors: The Professionalization of the Gubernatorial Corps//The Slavonic and East European Review. 1980, October. Vol.58. -№4. -P.541 -560
Pintner W.M., Rowney D.K. Officialdom and bureaucratization: conclusion//Russian officialdom. The bureaucratization of Russian Society from the 17 to the 20 century. Ed. by W. McKenzie Pinther and L.K. Rowney. -Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina press, 1980. -396p. -P.369 -380. -P.374;
Pintner W.M. Reformability in the age of reform and counterreform, 1855 -1894//Reform in Russia and the USSR. -Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1989. -P.83 -106
Raeff M. The Bureaucratic Phenomena of Imperial Russia, 1700 -1905//The American Historical Review. April 1979. Vol.84. №2. -P.399 -411. -P.407
Manning R.T. The crisis of the old order in Russia. Gentry and government. -Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1982. -P.27.
Хеймсон Л. Проблема социальной стабильности в городской России 1905 -1917 гг.//Нестор. -2004. -№3. -СПб.: 2004. -С.153.
Sternheimer S. Administering Development and Developing Administration: Organizational Conflict on Tsarist Bureaucracy, 1906 -1914//Canadian-American Slavic Studies. A quarterly journal devoted to Russia and East Europe. 1975. Vol.9. №3. -P.277 -301. -P.292.
Yaney G.L. The Systematization of Russion Government. Social Evolution in the Administration of Imperial Russia, 1711 -1905. -Urbana, Chicago, London: University of Illinois, 1973. -430p. -P.320 -339
Weissman N.B. Reform in Tsarist Russia. The State Bureaucracy and Local Government, 1900 -1914. -Rutgers University Press. New Brunswick, New Jersey. 1981. -292p. -P.50.
Weissman N.B. Reform in Tsarist Russia. The State Bureaucracy and Local Government, 1900 -1914. -Rutgers University Press. New Brunswick, New Jersey. 1981. -292p. -P.44 -45, 55 -56
Yaney G.L. The Systematization of Russion Government. Social Evolution in the Administration of Imperial Russia, 1711 -1905. -Urbana, Chicago, London: University of Illinois, 1973. -430p. -P.320 -321
Pearson T.S. Russian Officialdom in Crisis. Autocracy and Local Self-Government, 1861 -1900. -Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989. -284p. -P.247.
Badcock S. Autocracy in crisis: Nicholas the last//Late imperial Russia. Problems and prospects. Ed. by I.D. Thatcher. -Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press, 2005. -208p. -P.9 -27
Modernization and Revolutions. Dilemmas of Progress in Late Imperial Russia. Ed. by E.H. Judge, J.Y. Simms, jr. -New York: Columbia University Press, 1992. -206p. -P.7 -8;
Armstrong J.A. Old-Regime Governors: Bureaucratic and Patrimonial Attributes//Comparative Studies in Society and History. An international Quarterly. -1972, Jan. Vol.14. -№1. -P.2 -29. -P.26 -27
Verner A.W. The Crisis of Russian Autocracy Nicholas II and the 1905 Revolution. -Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1990. -377p. -P.6, 51
Wcislo F.W. Reforming Rural Russia. State, Local Society and National Politics, 1855 -1914. -Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1990. -353p. -P.305
Хеймсон Л. Об истоках революции//Отечественная история. -1993. -№6. -С.13.
Raeff M. The Bureaucratic Phenomena of Imperial Russia, 1700 -1905//The American Historical Review. April 1979. Vol.84. №2. -P.399 -411. -P.410
Manning R.T. The crisis of the old order in Russia. Gentry and government. -Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1982. -P.27, 39.
Verner A.W. The Crisis of Russian Autocracy Nicholas II and the 1905 Revolution. -Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1990. -377p. -P.45
Yaney G.L. The Systematization of Russion Government. Social Evolution in the Administration of Imperial Russia, 1711 -1905. -Urbana, Chicago, London: University of Illinois, 1973. -430p. -P.337
Pearson T.S. Russian Officialdom in Crisis. Autocracy and Local Self-Government, 1861 -1900. -Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989. -284p. -P.253
Sternheimer S. Administering Development and Developing Administration: Organizational Conflict on Tsarist Bureaucracy, 1906-1914//Canadian-American Slavic Studies. A quarterly journal devoted to Russia and East Europe. 1975. Vol.9. №3. -P.277 -301. -P.281.
Seton-Watson H. The Russian Empire 1801 -1917. Oxford: At the Clarendon press, 1967. -813p. -P.733
Verner A.W. The Crisis of Russian Autocracy Nicholas II and the 1905 Revolution. -Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1990. -377p. -P.50
Weissman N.B. Reform in Tsarist Russia. The State Bureaucracy and Local Government, 1900 -1914. -Rutgers University Press. New Brunswick, New Jersey. 1981. -292p. -P.228
Величенко С. Численность бюрократии и армии в Российской империи в сравнительной перспективе//Российская империя в зарубежной историографии. Работы последних лет: Антология/Сост. П. Верт, П.С. Кабытов, А.И. Миллер. -М.: Новое изд-во, 2005. -С.83 -115. -С.87.
Yaney G.L. The Systematization of Russion Government. Social Evolution in the Administration of Imperial Russia, 1711 -1905. -Urbana, Chicago, London: University of Illinois, 1973. -430p. -P.330.
Pintner W.M., Rowney D.K. Officialdom and bureaucratization: conclusion//Russian officialdom. The bureaucratization of Russian Society from the 17 to the 20 century. Ed. by W. McKenzie Pinther and L.K. Rowney. -Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina press, 1980. -396p. -P.369 -380. -P.374.
Robbins R.G., jr. Choosing the Russian Governors: The Professionalization of the Gubernatorial Corps//The Slavonic and East European Review. 1980, October. Vol.58. №4. -P.560.
Armstrong J.A. Tsarist and Soviet Elite Administrators//Slavic Review. -1972, March. Vol.31. №1. -P.1 -28. -P.8, 28.
Armstrong J.A. Old-Regime Governors: Bureaucratic and Patrimonial Attributes//Comparative Studies in Society and History. An international Quarterly. -1972, Jan. Vol.14. №1. -P.2.
Raeff M. The Bureaucratic Phenomena of Imperial Russia, 1700-1905//The American Historical Review. April 1979. Vol.84. №2. -P.401 -402, 410.
Raeff M. The Bureaucratic Phenomena of Imperial Russia, 1700-1905//The American Historical Review. April 1979. Vol.84. №2. -P.409.
Russian officialdom. The bureaucratization of Russian Society from the 17 to the 20 century. Ed. by W. McKenzie Pinther and L.K. Rowney. -Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina press, 1980. -P.15.
Russian officialdom. The bureaucratization of Russian Society from the 17 to the 20 century. Ed. by W. McKenzie Pinther and L.K. Rowney. -Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina press, 1980. -P.369.
Mosse W.E. Russian Bureaucracy at the End of the Ancien Regime: The Imperial State Council, 1897-1915//Slavic Review. December 1980. Vol.39. -№4. P.616-632. -P.617 -618.
Weissman N.B. Reform in Tsarist Russia. The State Bureaucracy and Local Government, 1900-1914. Rutgers University Press. New Brunswick, New Jersey. 1981. -292p. -P.3 -5.
Pearson T.S. Russian Officialdom in Crisis. Autocracy and Local Self-Government, 1861 -1900. -Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989. -284p. -P.246.
Late imperial Russia. Problems and prospects. Ed. by I.D. Thatcher. -Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press, 2005. -P.8.

Еще

Статья научная