Преподавание в команде: обзор международных эмпирических исследований II

Автор: Брюльманн Ольга, Хильдебрандт Эльке, Марти Aстрид

Журнал: Непрерывное образование: XXI век @lll21-petrsu

Рубрика: Кадровые и методические ресурсы непрерывного образования

Статья в выпуске: 3 (15), 2016 года.

Бесплатный доступ

статья содержит обзор международных англоязычных эмпирических исследований преподавания в команде (team teaching). Работа в команде, обучение командой преподавателей сегодня являются необходимой частью повседневной деятельности учителей, например, при интегративном и инклюзивном обучении или осуществлении поддержки в классах детей с особыми потребностями. Кроме того, преподавание в команде и совместное обучение все чаще используется на практических этапах педагогического образования. Результаты с точки зрения эффективности и потенциального использования преподавания в команде и совместного преподавания порой противоречивы, в частности, из-за неоднозначного использования понятий, а также применения различных схем исследований. В англоязычных странах существуют более давние традиции исследования преподавания в команде и совместного преподавания, нежели в немецкоязычных, поэтому имеет смысл сделать обзор знаний, полученных там эмпирическим путем. В первой статье авторов, опубликованной в 2015 г. в журнале «Непрерывное образование: XXI век», основная информация о преподавании в команде была представлена на уровне метаанализа и метасинтеза в контексте инклюзивных методов обучения. В статье содержатся недавно полученные данные, связанные с исследованиями не только в области инклюзивного образования, но и других аспектов: влияние преподавания в команде на учащихся, учителей, на развитие процесса обучения, организационное развитие и пр. Предложенные авторами обзорные материалы представляют интерес для исследователей образовательных технологий, для методистов, могут быть использованы в системе непрерывного профессионально-педагогического образования.

Еще

Преподавание в команде, совместное преподавание, сотрудничество, совместная работа, подготовка учителей, профессионализация

Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/147112531

IDR: 147112531

Список литературы Преподавание в команде: обзор международных эмпирических исследований II

  • Aliakbari M., Mansouri Nejad A. On the Effectiveness of Team Teaching in Promoting Lerners’ Grammatical Proficiency//Canadian Journal of Education. 2013. № 36 (3). P. 5-22.
  • Al-Saaideh M. A. A Rationale to Adopt Team Teaching in Prevocational Education in Jordan//Journal of Instructional Psychology. 2010. № 37 (4). P. 269-285.
  • Armstrong D. G. Team Teaching and Academic Achievement. Review of Educational Research. 1977. P. 65-86
  • Baeten M., Simons M. Student teachers` team teaching: models, effects, and conditions for implementation//Teaching and Teacher Education 2014. № 41. P. 92-110.
  • Bryant Davis, K. E., Dieker L., Pearl C., Kirkpatrick R. M. Planning in the Middle: Co-Planning Between General and Special Education//Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation. 2012. № 22. P. 208-226.
  • Carless D. R. Good practices in team teaching in Japan, South Korea and Hong Kong//System 2006. № 34 (3). P. 341-351.
  • Carless D. R., Walker E. Effective Team Teaching between Local and Native-speaking English Teachers//Language and Education. 2006. № 20 (6). P. 463-477.
  • Carley H. F. Team teaching styles utilized in Japan: do they really work?//Journal of International Education Research. 2013. № 9 (3). P. 247-262.
  • Carpenter D. M., Crawford L., & Walden R. Testing the efficacy of team teaching//Learning Environment Research. 2007. № 10. P. 53-65.
  • Chang L.-C., Lee G. C. A team-teaching model for practicing project-based learning in high school: Collaboration between computer and subject teachers//Computers & Education. 2010. № 55 (3) P. 961-969.
  • Chanmugam A., Gerlach B. A co-teaching model for developing future educators’ teaching effectiveness//International Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education. 2013. № 25 (1). P. 110-117.
  • Chiasson K., Yearwood J.-A. & Olsen G. The best of both worlds: Combining ECE and ECSE philosophies and best practices through a coteaching model//Journal of Early Childhood Teacher Education. 2006. № 27 (3). P. 303-312.
  • Cremin H., Thomas G., Vincett K. Learning zones: an evaluation of three models for improving learning through teacher/teaching assistant teamwork//Support for Learning. 2003. № 18 (4). P. 145-161.
  • Dugan K., Letterman M. Student appraisals of collaborative teaching//College Teaching. 2008. № 56 (1). P. 11-16.
  • Gerretson H., Bosnick J., Schofield K. A Case for Content Specialists as the Elementary Classroom Teacher//The Teacher Educator. 2008. № 43 (4). P. 302-314.
  • Graue E., Hatch K., Rao K., Oen D. The Wisdom of Class-size Reduction//American Educational Reserach Journal. 2007. № 44 (3). P. 670-700.
  • Gurgur H., Uzuner Y. Examining the implementation of two co-teaching models: team teaching and station teaching//International Journal of Inclusive Education. 2011. № 15 (6). P. 589-610.
  • Helms M. M., Alvis J. M., Willis M. Planning and Implementing Shared Teaching: An MBA Team-Teaching Case Study//Journal of Education for Business. 2005. № 81 (1). P. 29-34.
  • Hildebrandt E., Marty A., Stommel S. Teamteaching -Eine Übersicht über internationale empirische Forschung I.//Lebensbegleitendes Lernen. 2015. № 2 (10). URL: http://lll21.petrsu.ru/journal/article_de.php?id=2808 (дата обращения 24.03.16).
  • Huber B. Teamteaching. Bilanz und Perspektiven. Europäische Hochschulschriften. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang, Europäischer Verlag der Wissenschaften, 2000.
  • Jang S.-J. Research on the effects of team teaching upon two secondary school teachers//Educational Research. 2006. № 48 (2). P. 177-194.
  • Kamens M. W., Susko J. P., Elliott J. S. Evaluation and supervision of co-teaching: a study of administrator pracices in New Jersey//NASSP Bulletin. 2013. № 97 (2). P. 166-190.
  • King-Sears M. E., Brawand A. E., Jenkins, M. C., Preston-Smith, S. Co-teaching perspectives from secondary science co-teachers and their students with disabilities//Journal of Science Teacher Education. 2014. № 25. P. 651-680.
  • Magiera K., Zigmond N. Co-Teaching in Middle School Classrooms under Routine Conditions: Does the Instructional Experience Differ for Students with Disabilities in Co-Taught and Solo-Taught Classes//Learning Disabilities Research and Practice. 2005. № 20 (2). P. 79-85.
  • McCormack L., Finlayson O. E., McCloughlin T. J. J. The CASE programme implemented across the primary and secondary school transition in Ireland//International Journal of Science Education. 2014. № 36 (17). P. 2892-2917.
  • McDuffie K. A., Mastropieri M. A., Scruggs T. E. Differential effects of peer tutoring in co-taught and non-co-taught classes: results for content learning and student-teacher interactions//Exceptional Children. 2009. № 75 (4). P. 493-510.
  • Murata R. What does team teaching mean? A case study of interdisciplinary teaming//The Journal of Educational Research. 2002. № 96 (2). P. 67-77.
  • Murawski W. W. Student outcomes in co-taught secondary english classes: How can we improve?//Reading & Writing Quarterly. 2006. № 22 (3). P. 227-247.
  • Murawski W. W., Swanson H. L. A Meta-Analysis of Co-Teaching. Where are the Data?//Remedial and Special Education. 2001. Vol. 22. №. 5. P. 258-267.
  • Pratt S. Achieving symbiosis: working through challenges found in co-teaching to achieve effective co-teaching relationships//Teaching and Teacher Education. 2014. № 41. P. 1-12.
  • Rivera E. A., McMahon S. D., Keys C. B. Collaborative teaching: school implementation and connections with outcomes among students with disabilities//Journal of Prevention & Intervention in the Community. 2014. № 42 (1). P. 72-85.
  • Robbins C., Searby L. Exploring parental involvement strategies utilized by middle school interdisciplinary teams//School Community Journal. 2013. № 23 (2). P. 113-136.
  • Roth W.-M., Boyd N. Coteaching, as colearning, is praxis//Research in Science Education. 1999. № 29 (1). P. 51-67.
  • Rytivaara A., Kershner R. Co-teaching as a context for teachers’ professional learning and joint knowledge construction//Teaching and Teacher Education. 2012. № 28. P. 999-1008.
  • Schustereit R. C. Team-Teaching and Academic Achievement//Improving College and University Teaching. 1980. № 28 (2). P. 85-89.
  • Scruggs Th. E., Mastropieri M. A., McDuffie K. A. Co-Teaching in Inclusive Classrooms: A Metasynthesis of Qualitative Research//Council for Exceptional Children. 2007. Vol. 73. №. 4. P. 392-416.
  • Strogilos V., Tragoulia E. Inclusive and collaborative practices in co-taught classrooms: Roles and responsibilities for teachers and parents//Teaching and Teacher Education. 2013. № 35. P. 81-91.
  • Sweigart C. A., Landrum T. J. The impact of number of adults on instruction: implications for co-teaching//Preventing School Failure: Alternative Education for Children and Youth. 2015. № 59 (1). P. 22-29.
  • Tajino A., Walker L. Perspectives on team teaching by students and teachers: Exploring foundations for team learning. Language//Culture and Curriculum. 1998. № 11 (1). P. 113-131.
  • Takala M., Uusitalo-Malmivaara L. A one-year study of the development of co-teaching in four Finnish schools//European Journal of Special Needs Education. 2012. № 27 (3). P. 373-390.
  • Tremblay P. Comparative outcomes of two instructional models for students with learning disabilities: inclusion with co-teaching and solo-taught special education//Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs. 2013. № 13 (4). P. 251-258.
  • Wadkins T., Miller R. L., Woszniak W. Team teaching: Student satisfaction and performance//Teaching of Psychology. 2006. № 3 (2). P. 118-120.
  • Welch M. Descriptive analysis of team teaching in two elementary classrooms: A formative experimental approach//Remedial and Special Education. 2000. № 21 (6). P. 366-376.
  • Wilson G. L., Michaels C. A. General and special education students’ perception of co-teaching: implications for secondary-level literacy instruction//Reading and Writing Quarterly. 2006. № 22 (3). P. 205-225.
  • Wöllner C., Ginsborg J. Team teaching in the conservatoire: the views of music performance staff and students//British Journal of Music Education. 2011. № 28 (3). P. 301-323.
  • York-Barr J., Ghere G., Sommerness J. Collaborative teaching to increase all student learning: A three-year urban elementary case study//Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk. 2007. № 12 (3). P. 301-335.
  • Zigmond N. Reading and Writing in Co-Taught Secondary School Social Studies Classrooms: A Reality Check//Reading & Writing Quarterly. 2006. № 22 (3). P. 249-268.
Еще
Статья научная