WORKPLACE AND LEGAL CULTURE OF EMPLOYEES AND EMPLOYERS IN RUSSIA: MODERN CHALLENGES THROUGH THE LENS OF HISTORY
Автор: Demidov, N. V.
Журнал: EUROPEAN AND ASIAN LAW REVIEW.
Рубрика: публично-правовые (государственно-правовые науки)
Статья в выпуске: 5 (2), 2022 года.
Бесплатный доступ
The work is aimed at examining the issues related to the impact of the industry-specific workplace and legal culture on enforcing labor law standards in Russia. The focus is on historical continuity of national legal culture phenomena and its negative aspects that hinder enforcement of labor law standards in practice. The research was conducted with a comparative-historical diachronic approach using sociological method tools within the general framework of an anthropological approach. Based on the results of the research, the structural elements of the industry-specific legal culture were identified, its manifestations for employees and employers as labor market key players were described. The essence of each element is described as well. Parallels are drawn between the status of legal consciousness and legal literacy in the context of free employment in the age of factory-and-plant legislation and nowadays. The concept of historical consistency, implicitness of some workplace culture factors that have been distorting enforcement of labor legislation for more than two hundred centuries is presented. The major factors include low legal literacy of employees and employers, disregard for legal provisions, the penchant of Russian citizens for non-legal regulators of employment relations, inflated paternalistic expectations, legal indifferentism by employment contract parties, social alienation of employees and employers, and employee’s refusal to defend their labor rights in case of violation. It is concluded that existing defects of legal consciousness and legal illiteracy need to be taken into account in normsetting work in order to avoid the issue of the poor effectiveness of labor law standards in Russia.
History of labor law, factory-and-plant legislation, enforcement of labor law standards, legal consciousness, workplace culture, anthropology of law
Короткий адрес: https://sciup.org/14134864
IDR: 14134864 | УДК: 349.2 | DOI: 10.34076/27821668_2022_5_2_14
Список литературы WORKPLACE AND LEGAL CULTURE OF EMPLOYEES AND EMPLOYERS IN RUSSIA: MODERN CHALLENGES THROUGH THE LENS OF HISTORY
- Axelrod, P. B. (1907) Rabochii klass i revolyutsionnoe dvizhenie v Rossii [Working Class and the Revolutionary Movement in Russia]. Saint Petersburg, Obshchestvennaya Polza. (in Russian)
- Bezobrazov, V. P. (1888) Nablyudeniya i soobrazheniya V.P. Bezobrazova otnositel'no deistviya novykh fabrichnykh uzakonenii i fabrichnoi inspektsii [Observations and Considerations of V. P. Bezobrazov Regarding Validity of New Factory Laws and Actions of the Factory Inspection]. Saint Petersburg, V. Bezobrazov & Co. (in Russian)
- Bykov, A. N. (1909) Fabrichnoe zakonodatel'stvo i razvitie ego v Rossii: Lektsii, chitannye v SPb. politekhnikume i v Tekhnologicheskom institute v 1908-9 ucheb. godu [Factory Legislation and Its Development in Russia: Lectures Given in the Saint Petersburg Polytechnic School and in the Technological Institute in the 1908/09 Academic Year]. Saint Petersburg, Pravda. (in Russian)
- Gurko, V. (1909) Nashe gosudarstvennoe i narodnoe khozyaistvo [Our State and National Economy]. Saint Petersburg, Skoropechatnya P. O. Yablonskogo. (in Russian)
- Gvozdev, S. (1911) Zapiski fabrichnogo inspektora (iz nablyudenii i praktiki v period 1894– 1908 gg.) [Notes of a Factory Inspector (from Observations and Practice of 1894–1908)]. Moscow, Tipolit. W. Richter. (in Russian)
- Kanel, V. Ya. (1906) Sudorabochie i sudovladel'tsy [Stevedores and Shipowners]. Moscow, Publishing House of S. Dorovatsky and A. Charushnikov. (in Russian)
- Kruze, E. E. (1980) Usloviya truda i byta rabochego klassa v Rossii v 1900–1914 gg. [Conditions of Working Class Labor and Life in Russia in 1900–1914]. Leningrad, Nauka. (in Russian)
- Lappo-Danilevsky, À. (1899) Russkie promyshlennye i torgovye kompanii v pervoi polovine XVIII stoletiya [Russian Industrial and Trade Companies in the First Half of the 18th Century]. Saint Petersburg, V. S. Balashev & Co. (in Russian)
- Lenin, V. I. (1967) O promyshlennykh sudakh. Polnoe sobranie sochinenii v 55 t. [On Industrial Courts. Complete Works in 55 volumes]. 5 edition. Vol. 4. Moscow, Politizdat. (in Russian)
- Lenin, V. I. (1959) O stachkakh. V.I. Lenin o trudovom zakonodatel'stve [On Strikes. V. I. Lenin on Labor Law]. Moscow, Gospolitizdat. (in Russian)
- Lukashevich, F. A. (1877) Ocherki promyshlennosti i torgovli v Rossii [Essays on Industry and Trade in Russia]. Kharkov, M. Zilberberg. (in Russian)
- Mikhailovsky, Ya.T. (1886) O deyatel'nosti fabrichnoi inspektsii: otchet za 1885 god glavnogo fabrichnogo inspektora Ya.T. Mikhailovskogo [On Activities of the Factory Inspection: a Report by Factory Inspector Ya. T. Mikhailovsky of 1885]. Saint Petersburg, V. Kirshbaum. (in Russian)
- Mikulin, A. A. (1893) Ocherki iz istorii primeneniya zakona 3-go iyunya 1886 goda o naime rabochikh na fabrikakh i zavodakh Vladimirskoi gubernii [Essays from the History of the Application of the Law of June 3, 1886 on the Hiring of Workers in the Factories and Plants of the Vladimir Governorate]. Vladimir, V. A. Parkov. (in Russian)
- Mikulin, A. A. (1906) Fabrichnaya inspektsiya v Rossii. 1882–1906 [Factory Inspection in Russia. 1882–1906]. Kyiv, Kulzhenko S.V. (in Russian) Pakhman, S. V. (1877) Obychnoe grazhdanskoe pravo v Rossii. Yuridicheskie ocherki. T. I: Sobstvennost', obyazatel'stva i sredstva sudebnogo okhraneniya [Common Civil Law in Russia. Legal Essays. Vol. I: Property,Obligations and Means of Legal Protection]. Saint Petersburg, Second Section of His Imperial Majesty’s Own Chancellery. (in Russian)
- Pazhitnov, K. A. (1908) Polozhenie rabochego klassa v Rossii [The Position of the Working Class in Russia]. Saint Petersburg, Obshchestvennaya Polza. (in Russian)
- Petrov, V. R. (2000) Deformatsiya pravosoznaniya grazhdan Rossii (problemy teorii i praktiki) [Deformation of Legal Consciousness of Russian Citizens (Theoretical and Practical Issues)]. PhD Thesis in Law. Nizhny Novgorod. (in Russian)
- Plevako, F. N. (1993) Izbrannye rechi [Selected Speeches]. Moscow, Yuridicheskaya Literatura. (in Russian)
- Ruzin, S. V. (2012) Pravosoznanie promyshlennykh rabochikh Rossii vo vtoroi polovine XIX – nachale XX v. i ego rol' v transformatsii rossiiskogo gosudarstva [Legal Consciousness of Russian Industrial Workers in the Second Half of the 19th – Early 20th Century and Its Role in Transforming the Russian State]. Abstract of PhD Thesis in Law. Vladimir. (in Russian)
- Tal, L. S. (1918) Ocherki promyshlennogo rabochego prava [Essays on Industrial Labor Law]. Moscow, Moskovskoye Nauchnoye Izdatelstvo. (in Russian)
- Yanzhul, I. I. (1907) Iz vospominanii i perepiski fabrichnogo inspektora pervogo prizyva: materialy dlya istorii russkogo rabochego voprosa i fabrichnogo zakonodatel'stva [Memories and Correspondence of the First Call Factory Inspector: Materials for the History of the Labor Issue in Russia and Factory Law]. Saint Petersburg, Brockhaus-Efron JSC. (in Russian)
- Yanzhul, I. I. (1884) Fabrichnyi byt Moskovskoi gubernii. Otchet za 1882–1883 g. fabrichnogo inspektora nad zanyatiyami maloletnikh rabochikh Moskovskogo okruga I. I. Yanzhula [Factory Life of the Moscow Governorate. A Report by Factory Inspector I. I. Yanzhul on Activities of Child Workers in the Moscow District in 1882–1883]. Saint Petersburg, V. Kirshbaum. (in Russian)
